Yes Sean, all high level pool is taking the harness straps off and flying. I don't really understand why you consider straight pool to be an acid test?
Two words: endurance and consistency.
Sorry but running ten racks of the 13 ball ghost is way harder than running a hundred balls in straight pool. WAY HARDER.
Really? That's your personal opinion, which you've stated before. Why not go to the source and ask Rodney? I don't know Rodney, but since you're on his Facebook friends list, why not ask him?
And let's remember, Rodney is a short-rack rotation player to his bones. He'd openly stated this. I'm going to look for it, but there was a video with an interview where Rodney openly stated this, and when asked about straight pool (the interviewer was leading down the path of highlighting Rodney's quick pace at the table, and how much of a joy it would be to see him run a big number in 14.1), Rodney simply replied that he doesn't have the consistency to play it, that he can't focus for that long, that short-rack rotation games "suit him" because he can rest between racks. HE ACTUALLY SAID THAT, and to this day, it stuck with me. I'll look for that video for you, and when I find it (if it's still out there), I'll post it here.
When your shot is dictated to you then you must execute that shot regardless of how easy or difficult it is. And yes I understand about your "mind gets to rest with each break" concept and that is your psychological take on it but the fact is that the physical requirements are much different because every break in rotation games gives you a layout of balls where the shot choices are severely limited.
To me Rodney or any top pro can beat the ghost in rotation or run a hundred balls when they really set their mind to it regardless of what method of aiming they use.
I agree with that last paragraph, to a point. The "setting their mind to it" is the key part in all that, and that's my point all along. "Setting one's mind to it" means the game itself, the pattern play, and does NOT involve repetitive motions like aiming -- that should be embedded in the subconscious. If you're "thinking" about aiming, you're missing! If not now, then on the next shot... or the next.
Let me share with you that in this past 14.1 championship, I really enjoyed watching Rodney play. I was rooting for Rodney all the way, because he's a genuine great guy and I like his quick pace of play, even though his patterns were obviously 9-ball patterns -- his cue ball control was questionable many times. That didn't matter -- I wanted to see Rodney go deep. Unfortunately, he didn't.
The fact is that we don't know if Rodney was thinking about his aiming with each and every shot. I kind of doubt it. As you know with CTE once you get comfortable with it then it's pretty much automatic without much in the way of conscious decision making. At the highest level it's acquire target-zero in-shoot.
And that's my point, too. You'll remember in my original post in this thread, that you have to take the harnesses off and just fly. What I mean, is with all this discussion about aiming, one would think all these players are "thinking" their way through the nuances of aiming every shot. E.g.: "view the CTEL (that's actually easy); stand 'this' way and acquire this visual; position head 'this' way and while keeping first visual, acquire this second visual; bend down/over into shot, and place bridge hand on table, taking care to keep both visuals 'visible' and align to/between them or what-not; pivot cue tip to center cue ball, take practice strokes, and fire." On every single shot -- engaging the conscious mind to do all these steps. You have to ask yourself -- Really?!?
I'm not saying in the beginning learning stages that this is uncalled for; it is certainly called for to learn a new system, to ingrain and embed it. But experienced players doing this and "thinking" about it?
I hope you understand my point. I'm not trying to undermine aiming systems in the respect of not learning them. What I *am* trying to point out, is that at some point, that aiming system needs to be embedded in your subconscious, and you should NO LONGER be "thinking" about aiming.
-Sean