ken- I think it depends on the competition from other rooms in the area. If I had a choice between a room of gold crowns and a room of diamonds I would choose the diamonds even if it cost more to play. It will not take long for players, league or otherwise, to gravitate to a better room. They only exception would be the daytime players with no money that require a daily special. Find a way to offer that too and it won't take long to become the areas top room. Profitability? Now that is an entirely different matter. Having CJ there wouldn't hurt things.
I hear ya. I have worked on MBA, and did a financial workout on pool rooms and seen ones that had great ideas, great tables, etc, etc.
Im not saying having pieces of crap. I lived in Paducah Kentucky for a number of years and the pool room owner there had his tables recovered 2 times a year in simonis and they were PERFECT. They were old Gold Crowns, and perfectly maintained, and most importantly they were paid for. All they did was bring in money.
If someone wanted to transition to Diamond tables as business allows it, then okay. But most businesses fail, and most fail within 2 years. I stand by my advice to keep your expenses to the minimum.
Some above mentioned Snooker tables, billiard tables, 10 foot, etc. IMO these are the exact wrong things to spend money on unless they are used almost continuously.
Here in Memphis we have HighPockets. ALL GOLD CROWNS, they are in good condition (not perfect ) but they are successful. Why? Stacey is the owner, he knows everyone in the place by first name, is seen often, has leagues almost every night. It has great food, serves beer, and generally is well run. But the biggest thing going for it is I expect everything is paid for, and they keep expenses to a minimum.
I wish you all the best of rolls,
Ken