What's "priceless" is that you say you can defy physics. That "science" just hasn't caught up to you yet. That you can't seem to grasp the simplest of the physics concepts, but keep adding your own special twist to what really happens just so you can sell some more DVD's. Marketing, marketing, marketing, got to keep it going, or people will once again forget the infamous CJ that knows things about pool that no one else has ever seen. Even though much of the accurate stuff is actually common knowledge. Just like you stated in this very post that I quoted. Pinning was supposed to be "top secret", but all the pros know about it. Yeah, ok, carry on with your add campaign. And don't forget to keep knocking all the science everytime you get busted by it.
Warning: Very long book following. Sorry, I just have to get all these thoughts off my mind and open them up for public scrutiny. Blast away, I'm curious about what others think about this...
Neil, I do so much agree with you that CJ might benefit from a little physics instruction. After all, "The physics teacher is the teacher", eh? Don't hold your breath with this guy, though.
However, I have felt for a long time that there has not been enough research done on ball-cloth interactions to make definitive statements. Most studies regarding billiards have to do with ball-ball collisions. I have no idea how an engineer might set up the proper equipment to study the forces involved at the ball-cloth interface, but I'm fairly certain there is still much to be learned.
I keep reading the pure physics side of the argument, that there is nothing involved in a good stroke beyond cue mass, cue velocity, and impact point on the CB, but I hear just as many accounts of players who obviously possess superior strokes, and it always seems to me that there is something special about the way an accomplished player hits the ball that I never, ever seem to accomplish even by accident.
As they say, even a blind squirrel finds a nut now and then. However, I have yet to get the CB to travel 8' to the OB and draw back all the way to the other end of the table despite hundreds of attempts stroking the ball as hard and as low as I dare. Hundreds of scooped balls flying over the OB and into the pocket tell me I was hitting low enough at least some of the time. You'd think there might be just one time everything would come together and create the perfect storm of strokes that would accomplish the goal. So far... nada.
This much I do notice, though. Over the last few years of working almost entirely on my stroke and the "way I hit the ball", I have tried just about everything I have read in a book, seen in video, watched in real life, or heard discussed on this forum. Lots of wacky stuff I never heard or saw anywhere as well. I am finally starting to get what I would call a decent stroke, and I can do things with the CB that I was incapable of doing my whole life as a mediocre bar banger.
This goes way beyond just hitting the ball in the correct spot at the correct speed, I'm sure of that. In fact, I'm not even aiming at a particular spot on the CB anymore. I just "feel" what I want the CB to do and try to make it happen in real life. My success at this has greatly improved over the last few years, and accompanying all of this is the distinct feeling that I am just "hitting the ball better". It feels different, more solid contact, better sound, "firmer" hit, better CB reaction to the cue, etc.
I can draw the ball back several feet with a soft stroke now, where before I had to slam the shit out of it just to get it to stop. I can finally feel the cue "get through the ball", and when that happens perfectly I am always pleasantly surprised with the outcome. Physics has no formulas to explain this, but I definitely can feel it in my stroke, and see it in improved results. Stop shots at all distances are easy as can be now, and this alone has allowed me to learn some pattern play that previously eluded me.
Now, getting to the topic at hand...
When CJ first mentioned this way of hitting the ball, I ignored my dislike for the spam man's antics on AZB and ran down to the table to try it anyway. That's the way I am, I'll try anything just out of curiosity. The results were less than stellar, but I kept the notion in the back of my mind for future reference.
Then one day I was shooting some jacked-up one-handed shots because my back gave out and I couldn't bend over the table. I am always amazed at how well I shoot this way in spite of having no bridge at all. Maybe because I never lose sight of the aiming line while getting down on the shot, I don't know. I'm no Jesse Allred, but I do OK at it.
I had a difficult shot to make in the corner, one of them where a right-hander has to shoot lefty or use the rake, and I just couldn't feel steady without any sort of bridge, so I just held my left hand out in an open bridge position, waited for it to feel steady, and shot down at the ball off this suspended bridge. Not only did the shot go in, the CB reaction after contact was bizarre. It jumped up, came back to the table and spun for a second, then grabbed the cloth with the best masse I've ever been able to muster. I made shot after shot with this weird "air bridge" with similar results. I think this is the "immediate" swerve you were speaking of above. Then I put it on the shelf for future exploration.
Some time later I was advising a member who was having trouble drawing the ball. I told him set up a stripe ball with the stripe horizontally and try to hit the edge of the stripe
with the top of his tip and shoot down toward the bottom of the OB several inches away. Well, it didn't seem to help him much, but that little visualization sure helped me! I was "pinning" the CB the correct way, and my draw improved instantly. I remembered reading that Mike Sigel said you had to hit down on the CB to get a good draw or you would miscue. Since then it has clicked, and drawing the ball has become easy (until I get up to the extreme power draw stage, where I am as feeble as ever).
The most recent epiphany with my stroke happened just this month. I was watching the 14.1 at Steinway and was marveling at how Ortmann stroked the ball when jacked up over several balls. This has always been one of the most difficult aspects of the game, and it happens all the time playing straight pool. After his match I went down to the table and started practicing over balls, but I kept fouling as usual. Suddenly it occurred to me that the best way to practice this stroke was to eliminate the balls you have to shoot over and stroke the shot as if they were there. No actual intimidating balls to fret about fouling that way.
What I did was to shoot every single shot for several days using a jacked-up bridge, just like I had balls I needed to shoot over. This practice had unexpected and very beneficial effects on my stroke. I found out I could shoot with a real long bridge and down into the ball without creating tons of unwanted swerve as long as I hit centrer ball (no, I did
not try using a "touch of inside" lol), and the balls were just dropping in the pocket.
For me, I am convinced I finally learned to "pin" the ball, using a natural pendulum stroke like Chris Renfro mentions with just a touch of that hammer finish (TOH) that CJ is constantly going on about. And it works great for me... at least until the next stroke revelation comes along and alters things a bit.:wink:
So have at it. Am I onto something different, or is this just the way all good players stroke the ball?