I’ve been experimenting with 100% solid acrylic for a few months now; silver cup, champion chalks are not having any kind of affect yet on the sheen and, I shoot every day. As for as the effect on the shot - the feel, sound and outcome of the shot; I haven’t come to any conclusion that this isn’t going to work, the sight drilling gives me more confidence on a line to the target with the ferrule staying clean seems to be the benefit.
I take it to 2000 grit wet sand, then finish with a burnished applied high gloss boat polish, then use a soft cloth to clean and buff every once in a while. The high gloss polish with the cleaning over time does not last; the acrylic naturally at a 2000 grit finish has its own gloss finish that holds and repels anything that comes in contact with it. Here is a
link to what I’ve done so far.