2016 US Open 9 ball/ 9ft (16-22 Oct2016) Norfolk, Virginia (Winner $50K)

How can someone make a ball on the break and be illegal break? :rolleyes:
They really need to switch to 2 balls to the end rail next year.
Three is too much.

The commentators use the term 'non-regulation break', which I think is better.
But the rule sucks anyway.
 
JJ gets the extra effort award, for sure. His opponents have averaged 9 games against him, so he's fought his way to the finish line in every match. And he's no spring chicken! Congrats!

JJ beats Alex 11-9!

What a great tournament for JJ so far.
 
How can someone make a ball on the break and be illegal break?


Well, one reason that stands out is the US Open finals in 2001, Corey v Mika. Corey was soft breaking and somehow making 1, 2, even 3 balls on the break. But no OB's were even passing the middle of the table. It's amazing to watch once, but gets old fast.
 
Well, one reason that stands out is the US Open finals in 2001, Corey v Mika. Corey was soft breaking and somehow making 1, 2, even 3 balls on the break. But no OB's were even passing the middle of the table. It's amazing to watch once, but gets old fast.

I don't like the soft break, but there's gotta be a better way to set up the rules to prevent it. I suggested putting a radar gun on the break and having a minimum break speed.
 
pocketing, or making, 3 balls past the head string seems to generate a lot of illegal breaks where us league players would nod our heads and say the breaker did try to break hard.

How about the same rule, but 3 balls need to travel past the 3rd diamond (instead of the 2nd diamond)?
 
pocketing, or making, 3 balls past the head string seems to generate a lot of illegal breaks where us league players would nod our heads and say the breaker did try to break hard.

How about the same rule, but 3 balls need to travel past the 3rd diamond (instead of the 2nd diamond)?

Whatever the rule is, it should never penalize a player who breaks the balls hard.
 
Back
Top