If you're going to troll someone, do it accurately. Don't post the part that suits you; post the whole thing.
"It's not even the OP that's resurrecting this 12-year-old thread. Scott's been posting beautiful new work on Facebook since at least 2023, and no one there is complaining. Maybe everyone should let it go if it wasn't your deal and use all the advice you've seen on AZ on how to safely buy a new cue."
Addressing your crap logic and even crappier morality in this case is not "trolling".
Nothing in the rest of your post changed anything in the least, hence why I didn't quote that part. It wasn't the OP who resurrected the thread--immaterial to the issue. You feel Scott does beautiful work--immaterial to the issue. You haven't seen any theft complaints about him on his Facebook page in the last couple of years--immaterial to the issue (not to mention that there could have been some that you missed, or that Scott deleted before you saw them, but even if there weren't, still immaterial to the issue).
The issue is that sometimes, not every time, but sometimes the dude decides to steal, and as far as we know he still has not made at least this case of his theft right (which is why the person resurrected the thread, to confirm that was still the case).
Someone sincerely admitting to their mistakes and making them right can in some circumstances be grounds for "forgive and forget" second chances, but your attempted excuses of "it wasn't you he stole from" and "Scott makes good cues" and "in the last couple of years I haven't seen complaints of theft on his Facebook page where he could just be deleting those complaints before I see them" are not good enough reasons for everybody to just pretend that the thieving never happened, or that it couldn't easily happen again.
The signature in your post says you own one of his cues. Maybe you are just a biased friend or admirer of his. Maybe you are trying to protect the value of your cue. But for whatever the reason, your take on this one is devoid of logic and morality, and I think you know that but are allowing yourself to do it anyway for one of the above or similar reasons.