I agree, and thus far have wanted to stay out of this. I don't believe a good portion of any of these stories, and as far as I'm concerned, any run done on a bar box or with a Sardo rack doesn't count.
I say that because bar table 9-ball is not a difficult game. It's impossible for a player of Matlock's ability to ever miss a makeable shot, so it is not surprising to me at all that he can run that many racks. The first time I played bar table 9 ball was literally the first game of the Open tournament at Hopkins' Expo in 2000. Three days and 700 players later I came in 2nd, and I didn't know what the hell I was doing. When I finally ran into someone who knew what he was doing (Jason Kirkwood) I lost. All I remember was breaking and running a ridiculously high percentage of my racks, and I did not feel I was doing anything special at all.
As to the Sardo, I saw a match in the WPC between Neils and Mika where IIRC both players ran about a seven pack. There were like 3 difficult shots in the 14 games. The balls kept landing in the exact same spots (and for some reason they kept racking them in the same order), and making a ball on the break was 100%.
And who's racking for these guys? Opponents - or people that are trying to see a record get beat? Any player worth his salt isn't going to just keep letting his opponent make the corner ball.
I have been around some very strong players, at times where they were considered among the best in the world, and I never saw runs of the magnitude mentioned on this board. I've probably only seen a true run of greater than 6 complete racks a handful of times in my life, and I'm very serious about that. Of course this doesn't mean that nobody's run more, it's just the numbers being thrown about here are a bit too high. People have a tendency to forget about pushes, safes, etc... There have been times I've been practicing 14.1, and afterwards someone will say to me, "Wow, did you know you ran a hundred?!" and I'll know for a fact that I never ran four racks.
Oh, and Earl ran 11 racks for that million... but you don't hear so much about how there were 5 nines-on-the-break in the run, and the shot for the million was a 1-9 combination. (I've seen the shot though, and it was AMAZING, especially with the pressure.) Still, he basically ran 5 racks, peppered with a lot of 9-ball nonsense, lol.
- Steve