Paul Mottey
With $5000 I would beg Paul to make me a cue. I would offer for him to make me a $3000 cue and give him the extra as unretirement incentive. Probably wouldn't work but it would be worth a try.
Really, if Paul wouldn't do it, James White, Pete Tascarella, John Showman, maybe Barry Szamboti. The last two I don't know what you could get for 5k. I honestly wouldn't spend that on one cue unless it was Paul making me a brand new one. I would have a couple two or three made, I'm kinda working on that now. I'm collecting titlists one at a time and I want to send them out (as I rathole enough $) to be converted. Just got my first one from Bob Frey a couple weeks ago, now I'm back to hiding money till I can get another one done. The one year time frame is going to be impossible I would assume, I think top tier makers are about two years minimum and up to seven. Good luck in your quest! It's a good problem to have ( figuring out who you want to make a high end cue) later,
Tom