If the shaft is wood, you need a ferrule to keep it from splitting. A simple pad turns out to be not quite as good because it doesn't protect the wood as well as a ferrule and the wood tends to get pulverized.
If shooting with the last layer of a laminated tip due to laze.....toss in a good miscue with that frog skin then sure sure
Proper maintaining of the tip should be a given, just like predator voids that warranty if you touch the taint between the tip and the end of the shaft.
I’ve been using ferruleless shafts for a decade and broke with one as my regular breaking cue for 5 years. I committed the crime I mentioned above and it took a chunk out the side of my tip and a sliver 3/16” long 1/16 deep from the edge.
My fault, careless and lazy the sloppy stroke and lazy with replacing the tip.
So I felt it necessary to resolve the damage....and have it play a little tighter still.
So I did. It’s been fixed for 4 years now going on five and moved up to one of my two daily’s during that time.
Still haven’t seen any ill effects to it. I’ve owned and played with precentury cues to early turn of...well played, no damage could be discerned via sight touch and feel of the shot.
Dennis felt pretty strongly about that too and the topic was actually one of our last great conversations, as builders I know we were not alone, and not all builders makers or pool players or fakers have much for intimate wood knowledge.
Use and abuse are not one in the same and it’s self serving to chalk up said butchery as some kind of design flaw.
I see pics of broken revos. broken/delaminating and or busted up to hell ferrule Lucasi hybrids, Meucci black dots, red dots, Custom flat and pie lams from various makers and suppliers and every predator made including the revo and again so many busted ferrules they would have had a tsb recall if they were drivable.
Where’s all the pics and threads about the busted up shafts because they lacked a ferrule?
I wanna see some sciency stuff and a stack of polaroids of all this weak wood runnin round out chere haha
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro