Try this, on a bar box, Diamond box is probably the best way to go. Rack a ten ball rack, run 9...leave one out as your break ball.
I recently played 14.1 on a bar box (standard Valley with Simonis) and ran a 40, 46 and then 56 in all within a few attempts of each other. I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say I felt as though I would never miss (each run ended with a scratch, not a miss). I was using shots as break shots that aren't even break shots---- and shooting 3 ball combos, ya know -- stuff like that. I tried a few 9.1 on the Valley and I found it harder - fewer options. I didn't feel the congestion was a detriment on the Valley -- it was a bonus.
Now, I also tried it on a Diamond and it was a different experience. 9.1 would be the easier and 14.1 would be the harder (the pockets aren't black holes).
So, I think the type of bar box determines the best way to play (9.1 vs 14.1).
I recently played 14.1 on a bar box (standard Valley with Simonis) and ran a 40, 46 and then 56 in all within a few attempts of each other. I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say I felt as though I would never miss (each run ended with a scratch, not a miss). I was using shots as break shots that aren't even break shots---- and shooting 3 ball combos, ya know -- stuff like that. I tried a few 9.1 on the Valley and I found it harder - fewer options. I didn't feel the congestion was a detriment on the Valley -- it was a bonus.
Now, I also tried it on a Diamond and it was a different experience. 9.1 would be the easier and 14.1 would be the harder (the pockets aren't black holes).
So, I think the type of bar box determines the best way to play (9.1 vs 14.1).
Did you find 9.1 on a bar table helpful with pattern play when U transitioned to bar box 8 ball?
I think "ANYTHING".1 is very helpful when transitioning to bar box 8 ball.
People often ask why playing 14.1 is the best practice for 8ball -- when 8ball would probably be the best practice for 8ball. The answer is with 8ball, you might get fortunate to not have any clusters and pretty much have a cosmo out. With 14.1, you still must choose the pattern to run and you 100% always have to deal with multiple, multiple clusters to run out.
It's not only the practice of breaking up the clusters that translates, but the manner in which you do so (not getting stuck) that translates.
Just my humble opinion, of course.
Dave
How would you guys say playing straights on a barbox translates to a 9 footer? Meaning, if you run 100 on a valley barbox, what do you think that would be comperable to on a Diamond 9ft?
Just curious what the general consensus is.
Honestly, it's impossible to really compare the two. It's like comparing how much harder it is to bang the Victoria Secret model versus the fat slob lady who used to plop mashed potatoes down on your plate in the high school cafeteria line.... remember her? The one with psoriasis on her left elbow?
Is it twice as easy? 10x? Maybe the fat chick is having a rough day and doesn't wanna get banged at all. Maybe she bangs YOU whether you like it or not.
How do you have to come at the Victoria Secret model in a way she never expected? Takes strategy. Pre-thought. Uniqueness and cleverness. "Hey there... you don't look so bad today! What's your name?"
It's apples and cucumbers and the two don't translate well, imo.
My guess is 2:1. If you run 50 on a valley it feels the same as 25 on a diamond 9'.
JUST a total guess.
Would be interested in seeing what someone else says. I believe you have a Diamond 9'er in your basement, right? I ran in the 50's very quickly and felt if I kept going and re-trying, I think I could hit 100 before long. I could NEVER do that on a Diamond 9'er.
My guess is 2:1. If you run 50 on a valley it feels the same as 25 on a diamond 9'.
JUST a total guess.
Would be interested in seeing what someone else says. I believe you have a Diamond 9'er in your basement, right? I ran in the 50's very quickly and felt if I kept going and re-trying, I think I could hit 100 before long. I could NEVER do that on a Diamond 9'er.
Honestly, it's impossible to really compare the two. It's like comparing how much harder it is to bang the Victoria Secret model versus the fat slob lady who used to plop mashed potatoes down on your plate in the high school cafeteria line.... remember her? The one with psoriasis on her left elbow?
Is it twice as easy? 10x? Maybe the fat chick is having a rough day and doesn't wanna get banged at all. Maybe she bangs YOU whether you like it or not.
How do you have to come at the Victoria Secret model in a way she never expected? Takes strategy. Pre-thought. Uniqueness and cleverness. "Hey there... you don't look so bad today! What's your name?"
It's apples and cucumbers and the two don't translate well, imo.