About Selling Cues In This Forum

Nine Ball

Certified Rail Tester
Silver Member
Hello,

I have seen cues sell and then the asking price is deleted from the thread shortly after. Does anyone think it would be a good idea to start keeping the "asking" price up on the thread after the cue is sold for future referrence?
 
Last edited:
Personally, I remove the posted price from any cue I sell as a courtesy to the buyer. It is no one else's business as to what that person paid for it, and the posted price would not necessarily be an indicator, anyways. That is especially true when you wind up trading or with a trade plus cash deal.

If the buyer wants to sell it later, it does not matter, in my mind, whether he got a really good deal or not when he bought it. If he wants to post the price he paid for it, that is up to him.

I don't feel that the amount that someone pays for an item necessarily has anything to do with what he can sell it for later in his market. If I see an item and I want to buy it, why do I care what the person before me paid for it. If it is a good price for the item, I will buy it, regardless of whether or not the previous person is making a profit. Same thing goes for a loss. Why is it important for me to see that a person is taking a loss on the item? It is either a fair value to me at the asking price, or it isn't.

It is sort of like playing poker..if you don't make the call, you don't necessarily get to see the hold cards.


That is just my opinion.
Joe
 
Last edited:
Bamacues said:
Personally, I remove the asking price from any cue I sell as a courtesy to the buyer. It is no one else's business as to what that person paid for it.

If the buyer wants to sell it later, it does not matter, in my mind, whether he got a really good deal or not when he bought it. If he wants to post the price he paid for it, that is up to him.

I don't feel that the amount that someone pays for an item necessarily has anything to do with what he can sell it for later in his market. If I see an item and I want to buy it, why do I care what the person before me paid for it. If it is a good price for the item, I will buy it, regardless of whether or not the previous person is making a profit. Same thing goes for a loss. Why is it important for me to see that a person is taking a loss on the item? It is either a fair value to me at the asking price, or it isn't.

That is just my opinion.
Joe

I do the same and TOTALLY agree with Bama. I feel if your just looking to buy a cue based of previous sold price you may very well degrade the cues real value. Lets say I sell a $700 cue for $450. lets say it blue books for $700 and buyer chooses to resell it. Its thier business to disclose thier price they paid for. The cue still is valued at $700 if he wants $700 or $300 he should get full face value out of the cue if he chooses and IF the market will allow it. If we go back and start saying well you only paid X amount we will even futher kill this suffering market. Just My $.02
 
Bamacues said:
Personally, I remove the posted price from any cue I sell as a courtesy to the buyer. It is no one else's business as to what that person paid for it, and the posted price would not necessarily be an indicator, anyways. That is especially true when you wind up trading or with a trade plus cash deal.

If the buyer wants to sell it later, it does not matter, in my mind, whether he got a really good deal or not when he bought it. If he wants to post the price he paid for it, that is up to him.

I don't feel that the amount that someone pays for an item necessarily has anything to do with what he can sell it for later in his market. If I see an item and I want to buy it, why do I care what the person before me paid for it. If it is a good price for the item, I will buy it, regardless of whether or not the previous person is making a profit. Same thing goes for a loss. Why is it important for me to see that a person is taking a loss on the item? It is either a fair value to me at the asking price, or it isn't.

It is sort of like playing poker..if you don't make the call, you don't necessarily get to see the hold cards.


That is just my opinion.
Joe


I understand now. Thank you for setting me straight. :)
 
Last edited:
Nine Ball said:
I expected someone to give a reply back like this and thats not a problem. I just do not feel the "asking" price which was posted with the cue should be deleted and made a secret. It was there for everyone to see the "ASKING" price when posted. It shouldn't be a secret. Your right, If the buyer wants to sell it later then what he paid for it should not matter. I agree with that totally. I still don't feel the asking price should be made a secret once the cue has sold. I'm sure I'll be the only one to think this. So nevermind.
Once the cue sold the selling price to the buyer should not matter to you if your not the buyer !
I also remove selling prices as a courtesy to the buyer .
Alot of the higher end stuff dose not even get a price listed to the general forum...
 
Gotta agree with bama

The selling price of an item is only truly for the buyer and the seller, and who is to say the asking price in the post is that price?? Not my business, unless I am one of the 2 groups involved with the specific transaction. Just because it sold today for $150, that does not mean it can't become more valuable in a few months. An item is only worth what somebody will pay for it, and what the owner will sell it for, and that changes over time and with owners and buyers.
Isn't there already enough haggling??
You could always buy all the items on the board, and then you would always know the selling price:D;) :p

Josh,

So why the change of heart on this price deletion on posts when an item sells???


JMHO -Michael
 
GoTulane said:
You could always buy all the items on the board, and then you would always know the selling price:D;) :p
Pure genius !!!
Got to love all the brains around here !!
 
and the ship has sunk

Ok, ok.... I agree with you guys. Deleting the price is a good thing to do. I liked the idea so much I joined the wagon and deleted all the prices off my sold items as well. :p If you can't beat em, Join em. :D I just hate seeing a cue for the first time 20 minutes after it sold and i'm left wondering how much the asking price was. Guess I could never sleep and always hit refresh page every 10 seconds. :) Then I would never miss a price. :p
 
Nine Ball said:
Ok, ok.... I agree with you guys. Deleting the price is a good thing to do. I liked the idea so much I joined the wagon and deleted all the prices off my sold items as well. :p If you can't beat em, Join em. :D I just hate seeing a cue for the first time 20 minutes after it sold and i'm left wondering how much the asking price was. Guess I could never sleep and always hit refresh page every 10 seconds. :) Then I would never miss a price. :p
Hi,
My name is Bill and I'm a cue junkie !!
Welcome to the club !! ;)
 
Ok heres another reason a good reason to delete :) just have to add this a couple nights ago aguy was willing to sell 3 titlist cues for $300 i was working on the deal but missed out I would have been better off not seeing the post til after the cues sold and seen no price and i would have thought hey i bet he wanted 300 each and decided i did not need them. Now I am mad i did not act quicker knowing the asking price :D lol
 
Back
Top