Another Bob Jewett question: Rules For Golf Billiards Game

Saturated Fats

Saturated Fats

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Nearing the end of a game with three players the following situation came up and we are wondering about your take on this.

Player 1 has completed holes 1 through 5 and his ball is sitting so close to hole 6 that we don’t think it can be knocked out of place. We think that Player 1’s ball will be pocketed if disturbed.

Player 2 is likewise finished with the first 5 holes and trying to score the 6th hole and win the game. Player 2 shoots his ball at hole number 6 and both player’s balls are pocketed.

Who is the winner and why?
 
Saturated Fats said:
Nearing the end of a game with three players the following situation came up and we are wondering about your take on this.

Player 1 has completed holes 1 through 5 and his ball is sitting so close to hole 6 that we don’t think it can be knocked out of place. We think that Player 1’s ball will be pocketed if disturbed.

Player 2 is likewise finished with the first 5 holes and trying to score the 6th hole and win the game. Player 2 shoots his ball at hole number 6 and both player’s balls are pocketed.

Who is the winner and why?
Click to expand...
in one pocket if you make your winning ball and your opponents on the same legal stroke (it can happen when there is certain spots)
the shooter wins
i have no clue the rule for golf
 
Interesting situation!

What the written rules say

The OnePocket.org “Golf (on a pool/snooker table)” rules define a hickey as the penalty for several fouls, including any time you pocket an opponent’s ball. In that document it states explicitly:

You are penalized a hickey “any time you pocket your opponent’s ball.”

If you pocket your own ball in your own pocket but, on the same stroke, also pocket an opponent’s ball, “the shooter’s pocket does not count, and they are penalized a scratch.”

So under that commonly referenced rule set, there is no exception that forgives the hickey when you also make your own ball in your hole; in fact, the penalty overrides your make.

Snooker‑golf/golf rules vary a lot by room, and many places treat “hickey” simply as any agreed foul with stakes attached. It’s entirely plausible for a house or league version to say:

Pocketing an opponent’s ball is a hickey unless you also legally score your own hole, in which case the opponent’s ball is spotted/credited and no hickey is charged.

But that forgiveness clause appears to be a local or house rule, not something backed by the better‑known written golf rules.
 
Golf rules vary GREATLY from place to place. In T-town if you knock in someone else's ball they get the hole and you get a hickey. I'm not sure how this deal where both balls go in and a scratch is ruled. I asked DuaneR. to chime in, he plays it all the time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bbb
Was just told that in the two balls and a scratch scenario the opponent wins. This is how they play in Tulsa, if you make someone else in the out hole they win regardless of what happens next. Again, golf rules vary a lot.
 
Sheldon said:
Interesting situation!

What the written rules say

The OnePocket.org “Golf (on a pool/snooker table)” rules define a hickey as the penalty for several fouls, including any time you pocket an opponent’s ball. In that document it states explicitly:

You are penalized a hickey “any time you pocket your opponent’s ball.”

If you pocket your own ball in your own pocket but, on the same stroke, also pocket an opponent’s ball, “the shooter’s pocket does not count, and they are penalized a scratch.”

So under that commonly referenced rule set, there is no exception that forgives the hickey when you also make your own ball in your hole; in fact, the penalty overrides your make.

Snooker‑golf/golf rules vary a lot by room, and many places treat “hickey” simply as any agreed foul with stakes attached. It’s entirely plausible for a house or league version to say:

Pocketing an opponent’s ball is a hickey unless you also legally score your own hole, in which case the opponent’s ball is spotted/credited and no hickey is charged.
the rules?
But that forgiveness clause appears to be a local or house rule, not something backed by the better‑known written golf rules.
Click to expand...

Can you please provide a link to the rules?
 
I'd go by the 1P dot org rules for unusual situations if you don't have a good set of local rules that cover them. Here is the PDF of those rules....

(You may want to modify/add to those rules. There are some I've never seen in play.)
 

Attachments

garczar said:
Was just told that in the two balls and a scratch scenario the opponent wins. This is how they play in Tulsa, if you make someone else in the out hole they win regardless of what happens next. Again, golf rules vary a lot.
Click to expand...
Sometimes people will play if you make the opponents ball, you pay double.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top