Hi,
I don't think there is one cue maker with a cue posted hear that built their cue with the predisposition that no one would play with it. Building a Plain Jane and comparing it to Masterpiece type cues, then somehow casting a doubt the these fine cues aren't players or will fall apart is dog breath personafied. Very inappropriate and not the time or place for that type of talk.
I would bet the farm that each cue plays exactly the way that individual CM features in their design playability. To think any other way does not make sense.
I agree with your assessment that it is the people who own the cue that would be reluctant to play with them for other reasons. I understand there seems to be more value when they say unchalked and I get that.
JMO,
Rick