If you want to know who the best is, ask the pool stream commentators that can't focus more than 1 ball ahead. That group doesn't include Billy I., Daniel Busch, Fast Lenny or Joey A.
Have any of the above three players accomplished what Nick Varner has?
Nick Varner won world titles in 14.1, 8-Ball, 9-Ball, 1-Pocket, and Banks.
In their 1990 9-Ball Challenge Match, Nick defeated Efren 60-47, and that's at the time when Efren was playing lights out 9-Ball. The answer is no.
No one else has won all those titles, except Nick.
All around means just that, all around. You cannot count players, as great as they are, such as Efren and Frost, due to their dedication to games that avoid straight pool. Then, you narrow the field to those who really did play all the games.
Three names:
Harold Worst
Luther Lassiter
Mike Sigel
All the best,
WW
i think efren beats dennis still today
efren won the straight pool event in Maine in the 90's, and he'd played straight pool for all of one week before the tourney if i remember correctly...
Efren plays neither snooker nor three cushion at a world class level, not even close
meanwhile Torbjörn Blomdahl beat efren in nine ball
mosconi referred to celeumans as the best ever
alex p is likely the best pool player ever at snooker and should also be mentioned in this conversation
i have mark selby in the convo also
Anyone who watched Dennis Orcollo destroy Scott Frost has to think no one alive can beat Dennis in an all around playing all games. I been around great players for 60 years, NEVER seen pool played better than Dennis is playing now.
As a former Secretary of Defense said to me when there was no definite conclusion after a lengthy debate, "This has been a good conversation."
All the best,
WW