If it's so easy, then go ahead! You probably could get odds! I'm sure there would be a VERY big window open on those who would bet against you being able to win at all, let alone..."for no other reason then to just smash the trophy right there on stream, and tell em what a B.S. tourney it is."
Scott Lee
http://poolknowledge.com
I'll be a bit more polite. I watched the stream for several hours and can say with all sincerity, this tournament isn't representative of top amateur pool. I say this but you must understand, I agree with the concept of this tournament but perhaps have issue with its execution and I'm happy to elaborate.
For starters, it's difficult to define what is truly "amateur". I like the APA's definition which is strictly about monetary gain but, as inclusive as this definition is, the very best players seen in many other "amateur" events throughout the country fail to show-up for this one.
Why is that? Well, tournaments such as these cost participants a lot of money. There are entry fees, travel expenses (which, for me, include hiring a dog sitter), time off from work (limited for many people). We're accustomed to monetary compensation for winning. I'm not saying this is the correct way of doing things but it's the way things are typically done.
What's the matter with this structure? Let's do some math. Just speaking about the men, there are 128 finalists. Each finalist won a regional event that cost him $40 to play in. Most regional events had fields of 32 players. That means about $150,000 was collected, not including the $75 the winner must pay on site after winning the regional (yes, the winner digs into his own pocket and must furnish $75). In exchange, they get free hotel and must pay for their car & airfare. This puts the individual's commitment at around $500 assuming they get great airfare to Tampa and a great deal on a car rental. It could be as much as $1k.
And, on to the important part. What do you get? You get (drum roll please), a $500 entry into a pro event and hotel for the week (worth about $1k) and a really nice trophy. In my opinion, events like these are great but given the fact they collected about $150,000, there should be more prizes. Seriously, one winner and one hundred and twenty seven losers. That's kinda rough, if you ask me.
This is no disrespect to the person that won. I'm sure he's an excellent player. And, this is no disrespect to those that participate. I think it's important to have events such as these that encourage improvement, reward excellence and feed pro events. However, you don't need to be a mathematician to know that unless you're killing the field, you're better off sending a check directly to Barry Behrman personally.
If they hold this event in NYC (where I live), I'll play every time. As it stands, I really need an excuse to want to visit Tampa. I have relatives there so perhaps I'll do it one day. Like I said, I'm not entirely against this. But, make no mistake of it, there are plenty of "amateurs" who are disgusted by the payout and more disgusted by the constant references about it being a "top amateur field" when there are matches routinely displayed on the TV table of intermediate-level play.
The only thing I say in the APA's defense is, they don't lie about it. They're clear about what is covered by them and what isn't and what they're awarding. However, until there's proper monetary incentive, you can never say this is a true amateur championship. Those that are "in the know" will always reference the BCA Nationals and rightfully so.
With that said, I really would like to see more tournaments that sent players to pro events. I think the pool world could really benefit from a pyramid structure that offered proper payouts.