Hmm, misguided? Lets look at your linked thread.
This is amazing, Thomas Wayne, custom cue maker, has figured out something that we all don't know about elephants and their life cycle. Well, at least he "says" we dont know. People who actually strive to learn things and dont spend most of their time in front of reality television may be aware of such things as above. Unfortunately to someone like me his claim makes him come off like a ignorant git making the assumption that everyone who reads his speech is ignorant of the facts he presents.
I have actually been out buying Ivory before (GASP, NOT YOU, HYPOCRIT! At least I can say I do speak from some experiance). I have never seen top quality ivory for $110 a pound. Most of the ivory I have seen on the market is flaked and dried far too much. Usually it is also from small tusks of young animals that suck for cue making because the thickness of the solid section of tusk between the outer part of the tusk and the pulp is too thin to be of use other then inlays. Maybe Thomas Wayne has some secret connection for his ivory. I would love to know if he actually dates his ivory to make sure
Certificate of authenticity? What is the way he actually documents it? I would say short of dating the actual material he could not be sure of anything. But whatever he needs to do to make himself able to sleep at night and keep people buying his cues.
If he actually thinks ivory has never been smuggled into the USA I really dont know what to say. Maybe he should read this, he is pretty specific on what he chooses to study up on to provide support to his side of the debate.
http://www.traffic.org/news/press-releases/ivory_markets_usa.html
No doubt, I guess that is why I said
Culling herds is fine. ALSO fine and basically exactly what I said
BUT right now there is a ban on ivory. If new ivory is being sold then it is poached. Sure there are some stocks of old ivory, legal ivory, and you can also rest assured that alot of new ivory is laundered and cleaned into being sold off as "old" ivory. There is alot of "new" ivory in the USA and Asia.
By all means, lets legalize the limited sale of ivory and then regulate it. Lets make sure that the elephants are not shot and killed and only the tusks taken, leaving the meat to rot in the sun. Lets make sure that juvinile animals are not being killed for tusks 1/10th the size of a normal bull male because bullets are cheap and 2 1 pound tusks are better then nothing. Regulate the hunting and culling, charge hunters a slew of money to hunt a bull elephant, the whole market can be managed and then I have no issue with the use of truely legal ivory in anything.
THAT is what I had a problem with. Right now ivory is poached, it is smuggled into the country, it is pawned off as "legal" when it is often anything but. The whole ivory trade is a very messy ordeal right now and the last thing we need is the use of ivory getting "hot again" while it is a banned substance. Wait 10 years, sort out the messes with the actual supply of ivory, once it becomes a regulated and controlled market where the animals are hunted and culled with actual thought and brains and not by poachers then let the ivory come back as hot again. We dont need to be rushing to making ivory the in thing again until the supply is regulated and controlled and legal.
I wonder if Thomas Wayne feels the same way about Grizzly Bears and their poaching for their gall bladders, used as a aphrodisiac in Asia. I see the poaching of the two species at present as very similar and do not support either. I also see the sale and use of the ivory and the gall bladders as the root of the problem because if you take away the demand then the supply becomes pointless. That is common sense.