I play that a scratch is a loss but dry break I take BIH and begin. Many variants - if I really want a test I will play the ghost without BIH.
Cheers,
Gerry
I think jumping the cue ball off the table on the break should be a loss, just my opinion.
As for scratching, how about straight into the pocket is a a loss, but being kicked in, is a bad roll, so you still get BIH?
Fatz
I'd call it a loss with 9b + magic rack or some similar setup.
That's kind of strict but really there's no reason to miss the break shot.
For other games, I'd allow dry breaking.