Melissa,
Just finished viewing your match with Karen. I certainly haven't had time to analyze the replay, but all of us watching thought you definitely outplayed Karen. Speaking as one who thinks 9-ball is a terrible game to use to differentiate players based on skill level; I can say that we all thought your racks had a higher degree of difficulty, your position play was better (Karen had several fairly bad position errors), your banking was stellar (helping you recover from a mild position error in game 7). You won the racks you were supposed to win (of course they didn't show all the games). Karen was LUCKY.
You did miss 2 kicks that we thought you would make - DANG IT. I forget the rack, but when you cut that 2 in the side to get position on the 3 on the far rail we were going crazy - you definitely deserved to win (of course in 9-ball that means nothing). The judges gave you a 9.5, Karen gets the silver with an 8.5.
Just finished viewing your match with Karen. I certainly haven't had time to analyze the replay, but all of us watching thought you definitely outplayed Karen. Speaking as one who thinks 9-ball is a terrible game to use to differentiate players based on skill level; I can say that we all thought your racks had a higher degree of difficulty, your position play was better (Karen had several fairly bad position errors), your banking was stellar (helping you recover from a mild position error in game 7). You won the racks you were supposed to win (of course they didn't show all the games). Karen was LUCKY.
You did miss 2 kicks that we thought you would make - DANG IT. I forget the rack, but when you cut that 2 in the side to get position on the 3 on the far rail we were going crazy - you definitely deserved to win (of course in 9-ball that means nothing). The judges gave you a 9.5, Karen gets the silver with an 8.5.