Sorry but it sounds like a bunch of the posts I’ve read lately are talking about spoiled little kids. If they don't win right away, they never come back. Well let's just give everybody a trophy like they do with the real little kids so nobody cry's and pouts.
I really didn't even feel like posting just now, but I was getting sick to my stomach just reading some of these posts.
Where even in their wildest dreams should they think that they should beat a better more experienced player right away.
They can just maybe, get a chance to win when playing another beginner, like themselves. As it should be.
This mentality of giving so much handicap to a beginner, that they can beat someone right away, who has put in the time and effort
to get good (has paid their dues) is faulty in my opinion. I think this causes more disillusionment with and detriment to the game than some realize.
The whole beauty of the game is it's complexity and the layers of knowledge one needs to master to become proficient.
If beginners can win right away why should they go down to the Pool room and practice. For that matter how is this considered fair to the players who have already sacrificed the time, money, and effort, to become somewhat proficient at this game.
I've seen a good player come into a weekly handicap tournament and be given so low of a rating that they are winning more than a few times at
first then as soon as they raise their rating and their not winning they stop coming. Now how is this helping the tournament or the room for that matter.
It upsets the better players that know the person was rated to low and given an unfair advantage. You don't see the player that was given to much handicap coming down other days of the week to practice, why should they already are winning. Where is their incentive? For that matter the players that were coming down to practice get disgruntled and don't show up as much either. Now how does that help the tournament, the room, or promote the
game in a good direction, I'll answer that for you, It doesn't !!!
This whole handicap thing just has new players asking "what's my spot ? / what do I get ?" and the real answer should be
"with practice you get good". Spotting someone to victory doesn't leave them with a feeling of accomplishment or if it does it's short lived.
You are likely to not see these same people around six months from now. They have gone on down the road to find something (in their own minds) more challenging, this is a lose-lose situation in the long run.
Where as many tries to get that first taste of victory makes it very sweet and ever lasting in ones mind. This person is a customer for life !!!
A win-win situation.
I think helping a beginner is great but coddling them, is not. People appreciate the things they have to work for, or toward to achieve.
These people will have a lasting feeling of accomplishment and be around for the long haul. Just my opinion !
What are your thoughts ?
I'm glad you said this.
There's a tournament going on this weekend that's a big handicap tournament. I would like to play, however, my rating is a "10" - this means I have to give players that play like John B. and Lou 4 GAMES ON THE WIRE (going to 10) AND the 7/8/9 (playing 9-Ball). This is a LOT of weight on 4/8 tables alternating the break.
Don't get me wrong, I "can" do this, it's just a lot to ask for me to do it EVERY MATCH for the entire tournament......this basically means I can't make any mistakes (and break flawlessly) to have a legitimate chance of winning.
Meanwhile, the lower numbered players can win the tournament and never want to get any better.....because if they do their handicap will go up and I'll only have to give them 3 games on the wire.......brutal!!
I'm glad you said this.
There's a tournament going on this weekend that's a big handicap tournament. I would like to play, however, my rating is a "10" - this means I have to give players that play like John B. and Lou 4 GAMES ON THE WIRE (going to 10) AND the 7/8/9 (playing 9-Ball). This is a LOT of weight on 4/8 tables alternating the break.
Don't get me wrong, I "can" do this, it's just a lot to ask for me to do it EVERY MATCH for the entire tournament......this basically means I can't make any mistakes (and break flawlessly) to have a legitimate chance of winning.
Meanwhile, the lower numbered players can win the tournament and never want to get any better.....because if they do their handicap will go up and I'll only have to give them 3 games on the wire.......brutal!!