Just How Great is Efren Bata Reyes?

JoeyInCali said:
The Efren I saw in the early mid-90's was as good as anyone in history imo.

How old are you Joey??? How can you compare anyone to Willie, deOro, Greenleaf, Wimpy, Cornbread Red, the VASTLY underappreciated, Babe Cranfield, etc. in their primes to Efren?

Regards,
Jim
 
pwd72s said:
Possibly the best "who's best of all time" statement made here. But my vote? Mosconi. Kind of like when Dad & I would argue about Ali vs. Joe Lewis. We'll never know, but the debate will go on for a long time...

Ali hands down...to use a bad pun. If you can't hit him, you can't beat him!

(-:
 
‘Twas about a decade ago that I was glued to the TV watching the championship match between Efren Reyes and Francisco Django Bustamante. This particular championship was held at the Metropolis Mall in Alabang, Muntinlupa, Philippines. If memory serves me right, the 9-balll event was the third or fourth tournament sponsored by Motolite, a manufacturer of road transport batteries in the Philippines. The Magician won all the championships in the previous events. And he also emerged victorious in this one.

A sports commentator interviewed Efren Reyes before the awarding ceremony started. The commentator congratulated Efren and noted his incredible pool skills. I can’t exactly remember word for word what the commentator said, but it was in this respect:

“You (Efren) are the best! Barnone! Django couldn’t do anything out there! You and Django are “contra-pelo!” Every time you and Django clash, it is always you who wins! Et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.”

Guess how The Magician replied!

Efren Reyes wouldn’t have none of it! Efren, in front of a live audience and on live national TV, politely highlighted some of Francisco Django Bustamante’s accomplishments in both the local and international circuits. That we should not take anything away from Francisco Bustamante because he always give his all on the pool table. That Django is every bit as good as a pool player as he (Efren). That he (Efren) was just lucky that night and the position of the balls seemed to favor him. That to say he and Django are contra-pelo is absolutely wrong and isn’t right. That Django has beat him and other champions and notable pool players locally and abroad. That Django has beat him countless times too in all types of billiards matches.

Kinda gives one a very good glimpse on The Magician’s deep sense of humility and love and respect for the game and its players. Efren Reyes could have blabbered on about his various accomplishments in the sport and the champions and notable players he has defeated over the years, or elaborated on the amazing shots he did during the match, etc. – BUT HE DID NOT! Instead, Efren highlighted the various accomplishments of his opponent, including the losses he suffered against Django! This and so much more is why I sincerely believe that Efren Reyes is indeed the greatest player ever to wield a pool cue! And I kid you not!

.
 
Last edited:
crawfish said:
I'll give you an example. Pick your favorite player. Got him thunk out? Good. Now..... flash back twenty years. Efren could give him the seven, or 8-6, or thirty to a hundred and bet every last penny he's got. Make sense? Ask every one of them who scared them the most when he got to the states and got "known."

I bet people on here think Allison or Karen could hold there own in a race to 100 with him. Let the debating begin:D
 
those who continue to say that this old guys from the old era were better that efren...how would you consider this

if efren was playing during the era of mosconi , worst or lassiter..will they be winning lots of this championship as they were if efren is around??

now if these guys were playing today...would they stand out and still manipulate championships and can take claim from the fans worldwide that they are the greatest??doubt it

efren came from nowhere and then revolutionizes the game of pool even in this era of modern pool..it was a shock

now if these kind of playin came out from nowhere durng the time of worst or mosconi??what would be the mpact up to now...unfathomable!!!
 
tfdr said:
those who continue to say that this old guys from the old era were better that efren...how would you consider this

if efren was playing during the era of mosconi , worst or lassiter..will they be winning lots of this championship as they were if efren is around??

now if these guys were playing today...would they stand out and still manipulate championships and can take claim from the fans worldwide that they are the greatest??doubt it

efren came from nowhere and then revolutionizes the game of pool even in this era of modern pool..it was a shock

now if these kind of playin came out from nowhere durng the time of worst or mosconi??what would be the mpact up to now...unfathomable!!!
Good point, tfdr!
 
I believe that the question is best answered by looking at the degree of dominance of the player in question during their era. Who dominated more over the competition of that era?... and to what degree?

In general, the skill level of athletes within a sport improves over time. For example, the pro football players in the 60s could not compete very well at all in 2007. I doubt that very few would make a pro team today. The nature of competitive sports dictates that the skill level of the athletes within a sport will gradually improve due to the competitiveness of all of the athletes within that sport. Baseball, basketball, most all hand/eye coordination sports... the cue sports included.

Going back to the dominance factor... consider Mohammed Ali... Secretariat... Babe Ruth... Wayne Gretsky... they all dominated during their era. Their degree of dominance is what should be compared... not... trying to speculate who would win if they were IN the same era... just a thought to consider.
 
hang-the-9 said:
Tournament-wise, Efren is not in the top of the list. But he seems to win a ton of the highest payday items. It's almost like he just hangs out untill he picks a place to win. IPT is one, and the $100,000 Hong Kong challenge, which was probably the best 9-ball ever played in the modern era (not just by Efren but by Earl as well). The comeback he staged against Earl in the last tape is something to see.
edit - as to who is really the "best", every pro player poll I have seen (such as the ones BD puts out), the players themselves pick Rayes as best all-around player on the planet. Mike Seigel is up there as well, but from how he acts, he is turning more and more into "Minisota Fats". Every time he's on camera he is telling people "winning record against so and so, no-one beats me in the finals, I'm everyone's idol".


Is that Santos on the left?
 
Jude Rosenstock said:
Is that Santos on the left?
Jude - An earlier poster (on this same thread) stated that that person is/was a long-time (childhood?) friend of Efren's. I tried to quickly find it but couldn't.
 
cigardave said:
Jude - An earlier poster (on this same thread) stated that that person is/was a long-time (childhood?) friend of Efren's. I tried to quickly find it but couldn't.


No, that's the guy on Efren's left and someone thought that was Bustamante. I'm talking about the other guy.
 
Jude Rosenstock said:
No, that's the guy on Efren's left and someone thought that was Bustamante. I'm talking about the other guy.


That "other" guy looks like Snooky Villanueva, used to be a notch above shortstop, now a C player. The guy on Efren's left is Dick, a backer for both Busta and Efren. Nobody even mentioned Buddy Hall here, and THIS is Accustats Magazine's Vol. 1, No. 1 edition! :eek:


efren_caesar.gif
 
gopi-1 said:
That "other" guy looks like Snooky Villanueva, used to be a notch above shortstop, now a C player. The guy on Efren's left is Dick, a backer for both Busta and Efren. Nobody even mentioned Buddy Hall here, and THIS is Accustats Magazine's Vol. 1, No. 1 edition! :eek:


efren_caesar.gif


Well, everybody should know that's Buddy Hall. I swear that's Santos, though. It's really bugging me now.
 
Jude Rosenstock said:
Well, everybody should know that's Buddy Hall. I swear that's Santos, though. It's really bugging me now.



I assure you Jude that's not Santos, I've seen Santos in his younger days and up close back home...
 
gopi-1 said:
I assure you Jude that's not Santos, I've seen Santos in his younger days and up close back home...


Okay, I'll believe you but I'm never visiting this thread again. It's just going to bug me!
 
Are there any matches of him on tape from the early to late 80's? I will buy if you have.. Please PM me..
 
Bob Jewett said:
For dominance and longevity, several players have him beat. How about de Oro, for example?

Wasn't DeOro around in the early 1900's? There is no way that he had competition anywhere near to what it is now. He probably only had a handful of opponents on a regular basis. He obviously wasn't travelling the world and playing in zillions of tournaments like Efren has. A comparison like that doesn't have any merit, IMHO.

Not even players like Mosconi had as much exposure to this many world class players. There are way too many worldbeaters today that play many different games, compared to pool back in the 40's, 50's and 60's.
 
Last edited:
First time Efren played straight pool he won the world championship. That's pretty impressive.
 
Efren did not become a full time player in the USA until his late thirties. I saw him play in the Philippines when he was 22-27. When I first saw him on tv in the states, the only thing I could think was "What's wrong with you Efren? Why are you playing so bad? Who knows how many titles he would have won if he had came 15 years yearlier?
 
Back
Top