JB Cases said:
How do immigrants take advantage of our health-care system? It seems to me that most hospitals don't take people who don't have health insurance and most people who don't have legal jobs are unlikely to have health insurance. Hell, a lot of people who do have legal jobs don't have health insurance.
And I guess for the time being there are still some schools that they can enroll their children into without fear of being arrested when they pick their children up. But how are they taking advantage of our "education" system? They pay rent, buy groceries, gas, lotto tickets and other things that contribute to the tax base. So what if they don't pay income tax or SS, they are probably in an income tax bracket where they aren't going to pay tax anyway. And if they don't pay into SS then they get nothing out of it either.
And if they want to gamble with their income then that is their choice.
By the way, what is the difference between paying the kid down the block $50 to wash your car and paying an illegal immigrant? Nothing.
Or paying Fred Jones Lawn Service? Do you check Fred Jones to make sure he has a business license and a landscaping degree before you turn him loose on your grass?
Anyone who has ever paid anyone else for work "under the table" is guilty of tax evasion so get off the high horse. Every single person on this board has either paid someone this way or done work this way at some point in their lives. It's the way society works, irrespective of laws that seek to reign in human nature.
Quick show of hands; how many of us want to live in a world where we check each other's credentials with every meeting and turn each other in to the Gestapo when we find a "violator"? Aren't we living in a country that is supposed to hold as it's highest ideal the very freedoms we are eroding?
Good points! I for one is not in favor of anybody violating our immigration laws. However, this issue is such a catch-22 that until a wholly dedicated and truly well-meaning few comes up with the right and working solution will the illegal immigration issue be solved.
We are quick to blame illegal immigrants for the social and economic ills that beset us simply because they are easy and helpless targets. However, in the true spirit of humanity and freedom, we must also look at the positive contributions these people bring to our communities. Illegal immigrants provide the cheapest labor base. Jobs that nobody else wants, they pick-up just so they can earn a living. They fill low blue collar jobs that are vital to our economy especially in agriculture. If not for them we will be paying for 3 or four times for a head of lettuce or a bunch of grapes in the local supermarket. Besides who would want to be planting and picking these things in the dead heat of the sun with lower than minimum wage pay. True, they may also take advantage of the social services that may be available to them without fear of arrest and deportation but one has to remember, they are also human just like you and I. They have basic needs and dreams like everyone else it's just that they are in the bottom of the Wheel of Life.
On the flipside however, yes, without doubt they are in flagrant violation of our immigration laws. But so are the employers that take advantage of them paying below minimum wages yet ripping profit hand over fist. The employers must be dealt with just the same.
IMO, many (not all) of these illegals are hard-working well meaning people who wants what everybody else dreams and wants - opportunity, quiet, decent and dignified life, and a secure future for them and their families. Given the right solution, they and their children are assets to our country. In contrast however, we have many 'legal' inhabitants here that are nothing but leaches to the society. These are scoundrels and scallawag low-lives who suck the economic life of our society without giving anything back. Such is the case for people who make a career out of the welfare system, career criminals who bleed the budgets of the justice system or dead-beat fathers who could care less about their fathered children much less their child support. These people IMO are the leaches of society and should be the ones deported.
I was born and raised in our beloved country from parents who had served the US consulate as foreign nationals. My grandfathers fought for the US infantry and as guerillas in WWII and survived. I have been to many cities and countries around the world and never have I found anyplace better than ours. :wink: