Strange things happen
Joe,
You found one of my hot buttons, safety. I cringed at the idea of the minivan and would never consider it with other options available.
Strange things do happen. I pushed crews totaling hundreds of men over a fifteen year period. I was proud that my crews never had an injury requiring more than a band aid working very dangerous jobs in that time period. Unfortunately the first injury was to the superintendent of the job I was on, me! Blew my back. What I learned from dozens of injuries on other people's crews and from talking to other patients in the better part of a year I was in physical therapy after my surgery was that very often the injury occurred doing something well within the "normal range" of the person's activities, even something they did every day.
You and they both might get away with using a minivan fifty times or they may lose a few fingers or blow a back the first time they try it. Not necessarily from doing something foolish but just because of Murphy's law. Had he said he only had the minivan I would have issued some cautions and made suggestions for using it. When he has the truck and trailer readily available then I wouldn't use the minivan because it is easier to handle on the road or saves a little gas.
Hu
I thought yours was one of the more useful posts Hu. Not all of them were BS. I tried to be careful and specify a Dodge Caravan (or similar). I agree you can get hurt but I am assuming a normal male who has done a few things in life if he is contemplating moving a pool table. But you are right -- you never know. Perhaps your caution is warrented. No offense intended.
Joe,
You found one of my hot buttons, safety. I cringed at the idea of the minivan and would never consider it with other options available.
Strange things do happen. I pushed crews totaling hundreds of men over a fifteen year period. I was proud that my crews never had an injury requiring more than a band aid working very dangerous jobs in that time period. Unfortunately the first injury was to the superintendent of the job I was on, me! Blew my back. What I learned from dozens of injuries on other people's crews and from talking to other patients in the better part of a year I was in physical therapy after my surgery was that very often the injury occurred doing something well within the "normal range" of the person's activities, even something they did every day.
You and they both might get away with using a minivan fifty times or they may lose a few fingers or blow a back the first time they try it. Not necessarily from doing something foolish but just because of Murphy's law. Had he said he only had the minivan I would have issued some cautions and made suggestions for using it. When he has the truck and trailer readily available then I wouldn't use the minivan because it is easier to handle on the road or saves a little gas.
Hu