I'm not an expert on actual market value,but this is my honest opinion.
If your cue is truly in that nice of shape,and really if it has 2 straight,playable shafts and the cue was mine,I wouldn't accept any less than 500 for it. In a trade,you should get something along the lines of a 4 point Schon value-wise,but that's just me.
I had one of those before my 21 yr old Schon was shipped. I always liked that cue,mine was in the classic color scheme like the Meucci catalog,but the wood was nicer than the catalog cue,solid white wrap.
I got a good deal on it with graduation money for 400 with 2 shafts and JP's. I had it signed by Rempe himself after an exhibition in Memphis where I ran out on him after being randomly chosen during the challenge phase.
It was eventually replaced by a white plastic jointed Oldie 5 with a white/black spot open wrap cue that was supposedly made for Rempe but he rejected for whatever reason.
It got to me via an old Bob tactic where he was short on payroll,and partially paid his people with product they could easily sell on the street to make their money. I got it for 300 with 4 of the nicest shafts I've ever run across for a Meucci. After I got the Oldie,the JR-3 was stolen out of my case in Jackson,Tn.
After running 45 balls in 14.1 with my Schon right out of the box,I sold that Oldie to a complete stranger for 20 bucks with all 4 of those shafts,which had the ferrules replaced with the original Aegis by Bill McDaniel. I haven't seen him OR the cue since,LOL. Tommy D.