I also ran into 2 guys (that I know of) that played my events and someone somehow gave them a starter rating of 425. One was my friend of 20 years that I put as a 620, but I actually haven't seen shoot in 20 years! I think my local fargo league operator is starting everyone as a 425 by default. I emailed fargo and said this guy was way wrong, he's run 100 balls. And asked fargo to delete his starter rating completely. They said they can't do that, but instead will move the starter rating to a 620, which is about where he was after one salotto match with said league operator (who also knows this guy for 20 years) and they went hill hill. The league operator is a 670. That's why I'm thinking somehow whoever this LO touches in the system gets a starter rating of 425. He is honest, he def would not have done that on purpose.
Then another guy was a 425 starter rating with only 20 some robustness. I didn't know him, and asked how he played. I asked what his lifetime and 2024 high run was (he's a straight pool player). He said about 30 for both. I said I'd make him a 500 for the tournament. Well I screwed up, and had 500 written on paper, but forgot to hand type it into the bracket, and he played as a 430 something. He ended up winning. I didn't realize until it was over, so I didn't say anything. The next week he came back and I made him a 500 to start, and he was running through everyone, and I finally watched him with my own eyes run a couple of racks, so I moved him to a 550 half way through. He ended up losing in the finals 6-0 to the 620.
Now that both of these guys have played a bit more, their rating shows:
player 1: 646 (including starter rating of 620), 47 robustness. If I take away the starter rating he's 710.
player 2: 502 (including starter rating of 425), 98 robustness. If I take away the starter rating he's 581.
If the players come back, I think I will make #1 a 655 (I don't believe he's 710), and player 2 a 581 (I do believe he is there after watching him play).
I learned that in the fargo app, if you sort your favorites by rating, the sorting completely ignores the starter rating for unestablished players. Player 1 is between two of my favorites at 709 and 712. That's how I know he is 710 (or close). Same with the player 2.