I'm an old guy, tend to like old systems.
Or at least be open to what worked about them for a few hundred years before modern chemistry.
Old finishes and "patina" work for me.
Even in high end furniture, finishes have gravitated toward epoxy/polyurethanes/polyester.
Something i read once "clarified" it for me: "whatever the system, they are all still trying to capture the look & clarity of a true french polished finish"
Of course there is another aspect to the evolution of finishes: Do you maintain it? Which used to be expected and understood?
Or do you put something "permanent" (hopefully?) on it?
A third factor is market driven - if everyone else does it, how do you sell an alternative. Especially into a market with little tradition and no finish history. Fashion: what is the patina in 20 years of light maintenance vs under a coat of glass that needs stripped and recoated. Fundamentally, it's fashion & taste, which is all arbitrary and influenced by the times.....and again...."what everyone else does", "what is the standard look of the times".
Anyway, if you sell into a standardized market and make "quite a few" cues/year sold to random customers, i imagine modern car/boat/aero industry finishes are essential. If you make a few cues/year and don't care about pleasing the masses while reducing your finishing loads, french polish with fresh, shop mixed shellacs is the way it was done until nitro came along in the 30's and was not widely adopted until the late 50's. Shellac is superior to nitro because it does not soften from handling, and is easy to clean and repolish, or ever strip with alcohol and start again.
(snip)
First, it shines like no other.
fresh mixed shellac (not the stuff pre-mixed in cans) - check
It adheres like no other . If you find one that adheres like auto clear, let us know .
on wood, shellac - check
When we spray clear then have to take some off with a sharp lathe bit to create the top and bottom shoulders of the wrap groove , we cry if the finish lifts or cracks .
properly used, with shellac the finish is in the wood, so should not be built up like an auto clear. Within that context, the wood might splinter if your tool geometry and process is not good, but the shellac won't crack
Auto clear is so good, you can ding the wood and the clear will go with it and not crack.
shellac - check
shellac - check - before epoxy base coats shellac was the primary component of the better sanding sealers. It does take some technique and understanding with cocobola & oily woods
(snip)
But, I hear you about safety .
oddly, the largest market for shellac is pills and shiny candies. (absent the alcohol) it is edible.
Not interested in "converting" anyone. Any type of sales is market driven and experiments cost money. All systems have learning curves and few are "instant". They also depend on customer perceptions and expectations. Small amounts of alcohol will damage shellac instantly. Water less so, but more so that car finishes. OTOH, a french polish job is easy to fix, almost "instantly" if the finish is (correctly) not overly built up as original.
Primarily, my suggestion would be to people like so many of us, that just make a few cues/year for self, and maybe for some friends and relatives. We don't have the shop space for dedicated rotisserie booths, or supplied air hoods and incinerator vapor processing; maybe live among close neighbors, and the investment to stay safe or to spray in general could be as big an investment as the mechanical cue making machinery. As with any finish system research, and test, test, test on what is not a final product. You might like a given system. You might not.
smt
PS, per the other mask discussion drift: since retiring, my wife walks a few miles everyday. She has met and become friends with neighbors we mostly only nodded to in the past. Yesterday she learned from one she had not seen in a while that at least a 1/2 dozen locals, almost all "deniers" had been hospitalized recently, a couple of the more (visibly) healthy had nearly died. Many contracted it at one church event.
I'm taking a couple lessons: keep avoiding church, keep wearing my mask in the lift lines on the ski slope, otherwise stay in the shop and avoid people until after my second shot in a couple weeks.
