Chopdoc...for me, one of the reasons why I enjoy golf more, is because there is so little luck involved. To me, there is way too much luck in pool.
Interesting notion.
I would think that would vary with the relative skill of the players as well as the particular pool games being played.
I believe I have only actually played golf once. The fact that I was able to finish the game at all seemed to have a great deal to do with luck. I am fairly certain that my pool game, regardless of how rusty it currently is, relies much less on luck than my golf game.
There are many ways to look at it. In golf the distance and environment introduce an incalculable number of independent variables that cannot be controlled.
An example of this might be how much luck is involved in a hole in one versus a long shot on a tight 9 foot pool table. Then again consider running a rack, or 100 balls.
What are your chances of making 18 holes in one versus my making 18 pool shots? Or even better. I will wager that I have a better chance of making a run of 100 than a golfer stands of making 18 holes in one...or probably even one hole in one. One could say if the golfer actually did it, there was a lot of luck involved.
Of course, there are many different ways to look at it, but I think it may not be as straight forward as you seem to propose.
In many games of skill the proportion of luck involved seems to be greater when the skill levels are lower. A bunch of hackers on the golf course seem to be engaging a lot of good fortune to even finish the game, just like a bunch of bangers on pool tables.
Of course, considering the environment a golf ball has infinitely more possibilities to end up somewhere other than the hole in the ground than the variables faced by a pool ball seeking a hole in the table. You can hit a pool ball in almost any direction and have more hope of it finding the hole than a golf ball hit in any random direction finding the hole in the ground. Stated this way it would seem that luck can be more involved in pool. Even more so if you don't have to call the pocket.
There are many ways to look at it.
.
.