prefer viewing 8 or 9 ball since IPT?

smashmouth

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I gotta say I still think 9 ball is more fun to watch.

The top pros in this tourney seem to be running out at will with losses
coming via unforced errors.
 
smashmouth said:
I gotta say I still think 9 ball is more fun to watch.

The top pros in this tourney seem to be running out at will with losses
coming via unforced errors.

9-ball is more of a young mans game with eyesight, raw pocketing power a must and speed control what its all about. It has great shots and around table ball control that I feel the player enjoys more at times than the audience.
8-ball brings in all aspects of the game and makes it tougher for the younger unseasoned pro players (less than 10 years) to win. The non - pool playing public cannot appreciate 9-ball like 8-ball because of their limited exposure so 8- ball seems to be the vehicle for the public and the players at this point in time.
 
Irrespective of the merits of both games, I'minterested in what
AZ members prefer after now being able to witness some world class 8 ball.
 
probably 9 ball

smashmouth said:
Irrespective of the merits of both games, I'minterested in what
AZ members prefer after now being able to witness some world class 8 ball.[

I was in Reno Wednesday, and I found the 8-ball game harder to watch, because I couldn't see the total picture of how balls were positioned, which ones were blocked, etc. It also seemed that the pros were taking longer to shoot, checking angles and contact points, etc. I just think it's easier to watch 9 ball, but I'm glad the IPT is here and players have a chance to win decent money.....
 
smashmouth said:
Irrespective of the merits of both games, I'minterested in what
AZ members prefer after now being able to witness some world class 8 ball.

The funny thing about pool is that it is so easy from the bleachers, and that is not a shot at anyone. I should be a railbird HOFer. I haven't missed a ball from the bleachers in 25 years.
To me, 9-ball is still a tougher game. There are not as many options and once one is out of line, he has to make the shot and get back in line or come with an incredible safety. Then even when one executes the perfect safety, players these days kick like mules and return the safety or just get very lucky. Either way, over the years, the players have gotten so good that it has become to look very routine.
Then comes along 8-ball again and now the players are adjusting and seems that everyone is getting bored already with it. The cnditions are tougher with the tight pockets and slower cloth, but the true players are going to adjust to it. To me, the winner break makes it too routine. I feel alternating break would put much excitement in it and level the playing field even more.
Last week I was in Houston and stopped by Bogys, where Jeremy Jones works out.
They have taken a table and covered it with the Ipt carpet to help him get ready.
I'm a big JJ fan and as I watched him practice, I thought, man, this guy is ready to go, as he wasn't missing anything and his runouts after a while began to look boring.
JJ finished practice and left. I got the balls for the same table and started to knock em around. Granted, I'm no JJ, but I can play a little. The table was so slow, that i began to think I was playing with a trick cue ball or something.
My point, is that pool looks so easy from the bleachers and there are so many more players to make it look easy today than say 30 years ago. Years ago, there were the top 15 in the country and then there was the rest of the field. Today, if we take an honest look, there are about the top 75, maybe 50 more who are very capable, and then the rest of the field. Still there about 100 who are capable of keeping anyone in his seat for several games. This just wasn't the case years ago.
To me, the public has no appreciation as to how tough this game is and what it takes to get to the top 200 in the world and especially how tough it is to stay there. JJ didn't miss a ball and told me that the day before he had run 7 rack and then came back with 9. This week, he went out in the 1st day. That tells me how tough it is today. The man is at peak form, but sometimes the game is very unforgiving.
To me 9-ball is still the harder game, but as Ronnie Allen said years ago, "you will never get an audience with 9-ball, it "LOOKS" to easy.
 
8-ball is more enjoyable for me to watch, but straight pool is better then both, it's the best!


.
 
smashmouth said:
Irrespective of the merits of both games, I'minterested in what
AZ members prefer after now being able to witness some world class 8 ball.
I have several 8-ball matches on tape pre-IPT and went to the pro 8-ball tournament in Valley Forge a few years ago. Watching professional caliber 8-ball has always been more fun for me to watch, regardless of how easy they handle it.

Fred
 
First learned to play pool as a kid in a New York City Boy's Club, eight ball was the only game played. When I was old enough to get into a regular pool room, it was nothing but straight pool and friendly money ball games of razzle (variation of Chicago, fun game). At that time, only the beginners played 8 ball and 9 ball was strictly for gambling. Twenty-five years later, I wind up playing pool again, this time it's tough 9 ball tournaments, and it certainly and quickly taught me to love and respect the game. Still, I'll put 8 ball a notch below 9 ball, and two notches below straight pool. Sure there are some strategic moves, and watching Reyes play "ANYTHING" is terrifc, but aside from that, I find it pretty boring to watch.
 
best to watch: 8-ball, snooker
best to play: straight or snooker, but 8-ball as well. 9-ball sucks!

I think the break is too important.. The game would be more tactical when balls were put up in a square and you didn't have to run pack-balls to the rails...
B&R's are attractive to watch but too boring for real match-play. Alternate break is not pretty to watch, since it doesn't allow players to stay in rhythm...
New rule: ball made on break is foul. Only white has to touch one rail or more.
 
Back
Top