I like/ prefer the oil-rubbed finish.
I believe it needs to be redone occasionally though,
I dunno!........I acquired Joey Spaeth's 71 Szamboti in the late 70's.
I think that is how he ordered it..I really liked it.
Every other pool cue I've owned has had the shiny finish.
I wonder how many cues Szamboti did like that.
..and I've never thought of ordering one like that....
..is 'oil rubbed' an option by custom cue makers?
Post this in the Ask the Cuemaker forum and you're likely to get more/better responses.
Just a thot.