The more people describe that old style 9 Ball, the less I like it. I'm positive I like Texas Express better. Although, I agree with Earl Strickland. You ought to have to kick at the ball. He jumps, but only because everyone else does. He'd rather everyone kick at it.
If you ask Earl Strickland, Buddy Hall, Keith McCready, CJ Wiley, or just about any of the old school players, they will tell you that the new rules suck compared to the old way.
In my opinion, and most of theirs, the new rules have made the game WORSE.
Everyone has an opinion, so it is up to the individual to determine what they like best.
Earl doesn't like jump cues...neither do I. Neither do most of the people who learned to play years ago.
They don't like the fastest cloths and rails in the world either.
Everything was sped up to make things faster...not necessarily BETTER.
Everyone now will say that the current players could beat the players from long ago, but they are comparing it using today's environment.
Today's game is nothing like before. Back in the day, there were more "power" players than today. You had to "stroke" the ball to get it around the table. You couldn't "bunt" it like today with the fast cloth and rails.
Most players today would go down a level, or two, if you made them play on old school tables. I see it every weekend when I watch them go from one table that is fast and they are used to playing on all the time and then are put on a slow table. They don't have the "stroke" for the power shots to drive the cue ball several rails. They may be able to "bunt" the ball accurately, but they don't have the same accuracy when they have to actually hit the ball with any "oomph".