Sean:
I again want to thank you for your contribution to this thread. It has been an invaluable resource of knowledge from your experience that myself and others are sure to benefit from. So in saying this, I hope you take my continued questions and challenges to be what they are: further expansion on your opinions from a sincere desire to learn more, not attacks.
Nah -- heck no. I don't take your pursuit with follow-on questions as an attack at all. In fact, quite the opposite. I'm just conjecturing here, but I'm thinking perhaps it's because this info "flies in the face" of your traditional knowledge, in that you always thought you needed to "maintain control," at every moment, with your conscious mind. Certainly, someone telling you that you need to just "let go," and let some unknown dark thing in the recesses of your mind take over is very foreign. The precision required by pool and other cue sports seems to almost scream at you that you need to maintain 100% conscious control
at all times. But the fact is, it isn't, and doesn't. Pool and other cue sports are EXECUTION based. And reliable execution of a "consistently same" movement of stroking a cue is best done by the part of the mind programmed to muscle-memorize it -- the subconscious.
So here's my question: I have noticed that times when I go in to play without any practice when I am running late for league or a tourney I typically play better than the times I spend an hour or more to warm up. And from there it seems like my level of play in a tournament oscillates from match to match, not game to game or day to day. I feel like there is some connection of this with what you're saying about the subconscious, but I can't quite put my finger on it. Do you have a good explanation for this?
Yes, I do. I experience this as well, especially when I'm running late returning home from work, don't have time to stop by the house to get my cues, and just show up at the pool hall in my work clothes, pulling a cue off the wall to play with. I then get shuttled by my team captain right into a match, and I end up blowing the doors off my opponent. Yet, if I arrive early and practice, sometimes I find that I am guilty of the very thing that I espouse against -- and that's involvement of the conscious mind into my shot-making. The moment I do that, my game creaks and wobbles, ultimately falling apart, even though my stroke arm is fully warmed up. Not always does this happen, as I've had nights too where I warmed up with the same result.
I think the issue is state-of-mind -- when you're first walking in. If you have other things on your mind and are used to shooting from the subconscious, the conscious mind is occupied to the point where it won't interrupt what you're doing. However, on those days when there was nothing occupying my thoughts -- no problems, no issues -- those times are more likely where my conscious mind will want to intercede, sort of like it's asking, "hey, do you mind if I join you guys?" thing, followed by "step out of the way, let me show you how it's done." You'll feel "clear and lucid" -- but that's its own Achilles Heel. Your conscious mind is like the controlling neighbor, sticking his nose in business where it doesn't belong, and then bailing at the most inopportune time (e.g. something distracts your focus). Learning how to keep this nosy neighbor on his own side of the fence is a practiced skill. And admittedly, not all of us can do this reliably all the time. I have my trouble days, too, but not these sudden "I can't for the life of me make a ball" or "everything I do turns out to be the wrong thing!" catastrophic days.
-Sean