Underappreciated Cue Makers Section

The best cue makers respect the importance of balancing the weight of the shaft with the weight of the cue butt.
I’m not referring to the balance point of the cue but rather the weight ratio of the cue shaft with the overall weight.

Cues falling within that range overwhelmingly tend to be the cues pool players prefer the most, in my experience.
You don’t need years of cue building experience to emulate that approach or long periods of trial and error either.
Like the shaft being roughly 1/4 the weight of the butt or 20% of the total weight? How tight is the preferred ratio? I seem to like shafts that weigh between 3.5 and 4 oz I think? 🤷‍♂️
 
The ratio range I calculated to be ideal is between 18% minimum to 23% maximum. I prefer 21-22% for my shafts.
So let's say on a 19oz cue, you prefer a 3.99 to 4.18oz on the shaft.

and the ideal range is 3.42 to 4.37oz shaft.

Interesting. Just from experience in weighing shafts it sounds reasonable.

I prefer between 3.6 to less than 4.0 I think.

Hell, I'm not even sure. But this math is pretty granular. I don't think I could tell the difference between 3.99 and 4.18.
 
I'd probably add Ned Morris and Paul Dayton in there for good measure. Obviously Paul has passed so that changes things a little. I remember really liking Travis Niklich (Black Creek) cues, though I don't know if he is still building. His work was exceptional IMO.
Travis took a job at a technical college.
 
So let's say on a 19oz cue, you prefer a 3.99 to 4.18oz on the shaft.

and the ideal range is 3.42 to 4.37oz shaft.

Interesting. Just from experience in weighing shafts it sounds reasonable.

I prefer between 3.6 to less than 4.0 I think.

Hell, I'm not even sure. But this math is pretty granular. I don't think I could tell the difference between 3.99 and 4.18.
Keep in mind that there is a sweet spot for most players and when you match a shaft with a butt, there are other things to consider, such as does the shaft have a receiver which adds weight to the base of the cue shaft. With my cues, I told my cue makers to build shaft 4 ozs or heavier since the butt’s were 14.5 ozs. The cues have flat faced joints so the shaft weight is just wood, ferrule and tip sans any receiver. Personally. I think 18% is on the low side but i have played with cues with a KW shaft that was on the lighter side for my taste but the darn cue nonetheless played fine. When the shaft is too light, I tend to push the cue ball more with my stroke because my stroke balance seems like it was a short stroke and not as deliberate.
 
Keep in mind that there is a sweet spot for most players and when you match a shaft with a butt, there are other things to consider, such as does the shaft have a receiver which adds weight to the base of the cue shaft. With my cues, I told my cue makers to build shaft 4 ozs or heavier since the butt’s were 14.5 ozs. The cues have flat faced joints so the shaft weight is just wood, ferrule and tip sans any receiver. Personally. I think 18% is on the low side but i have played with cues with a KW shaft that was on the lighter side for my taste but the darn cue nonetheless played fine. When the shaft is too light, I tend to push the cue ball more with my stroke because my stroke balance seems like it was a short stroke and not as deliberate.
I have a Cog / G-10 pin. I had Joe Gold build me a set of full 13mm shafts and they were both over 4oz. Felt like logs. I had to cut them down to 3.4 and 3.6. Maybe the G-10 pin has something to do with it.
 
Keep in mind that there is a sweet spot for most players and when you match a shaft with a butt, there are other things to consider, such as does the shaft have a receiver which adds weight to the base of the cue shaft. With my cues, I told my cue makers to build shaft 4 ozs or heavier since the butt’s were 14.5 ozs. The cues have flat faced joints so the shaft weight is just wood, ferrule and tip sans any receiver. Personally. I think 18% is on the low side but i have played with cues with a KW shaft that was on the lighter side for my taste but the darn cue nonetheless played fine. When the shaft is too light, I tend to push the cue ball more with my stroke because my stroke balance seems like it was a short stroke and not as deliberate.
I would agree. I don't really care for flat faced shafts much lighter than 3.7. Granted the construction/weight placement of the cue/shaft has a role. Both of my AVID shafts are around 3.75 to 3.8 oz.
 
I have a Cog / G-10 pin. I had Joe Gold build me a set of full 13mm shafts and they were both over 4oz. Felt like logs. I had to cut them down to 3.4 and 3.6. Maybe the G-10 pin has something to do with it.
My guess is that due to the initial weight of your shafts (over 4 oz), coupled with a g10 joint pin, the overall balance point of your cue was too far forward. For my taste, anything north of a 19.25" balance point is a no go.
 
I picked up a Gold Rush cue (I believe I am the 2nd owner) made by Kevin McClain. A little heavier than my usual player (19.6oz), but one thing I noticed is the butt and shaft are as close to perfectly matched as any of the other butt/shaft that I own. To be fair most of my shafts I own are made separately from the butts. I haven’t seen him mentioned too often on AZB. Anyone else have a positive experience with cue maker and/or cue?
I've got one and I love it.

As for makers, my vote is for Scott Gilmore. He's making me 2 customs and an ebony Hoppe conversion.
 
I'd probably add Ned Morris and Paul Dayton in there for good measure. Obviously Paul has passed so that changes things a little. I remember really liking Travis Niklich (Black Creek) cues, though I don't know if he is still building. His work was exceptional IMO.
Love my Dayton.

The underappreciated makers are many.

Right time. Right place. Things like that can boost a name.

There are likely some greats that will go to their grave remaining fairly unknown.

When someone says my X is as good a Y (insert legendary maker), it is often met with skepticism anyway.

Personally, I think it's great to give a shout-out to makers.

Here on AZB we have makers. I always recommend to have a look at the forum where they post their cues, a subforum of the Cue and Case Gallery.

These are members of our community. Sometimes they are posting in the foums and members don't even realize they make cues. Some of them we have seen start from the first sneaky they cut down from a house cue.

Have a look: LINK
 
Once again I'll give a positive report for Mike Gulyassy two thumbs up , I'd like to acquire another of his cues but sadly that won't happen anytime soon so for now I'll be more than happy with what I've got now .
I have a 60" White Ebony one waiting for you. :)

IMG_2129.jpeg
 
Back
Top