What is wrong with this cue?? (ebay)

1pRoscoe

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I've seen this cue trade hands MANY times in its short 6mo life - I think about 5 different people have owned it and it's for sale again....

It's the ebony JMW hoppe cue that has been posted here a few times, mfg date 08/07.... I have never seen one change hands this many times.

Anyone have any insight as to what is wrong with it? This is almost exactly the cue I'm looking for....

http://cgi.ebay.com/JAMES-WHITE-PRE...ryZ21212QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
 
1pRoscoe said:
I've seen this cue trade hands MANY times in its short 6mo life - I think about 5 different people have owned it and it's for sale again....

It's the ebony JMW hoppe cue that has been posted here a few times, mfg date 08/07.... I have never seen one change hands this many times.

Anyone have any insight as to what is wrong with it? This is almost exactly the cue I'm looking for....

http://cgi.ebay.com/JAMES-WHITE-PRE...ryZ21212QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

I don't know, maybe they all flipped it for a positive gain. It's unplayed so that means no one really knows how it plays.. :) But it looks like a real nice JMW..

JV
 
There is nothing at all wrong with this cue.
I bought it when it was new for an investment.
Sold it to Mike with a small profit. Never played it because
I didn't want to chalk it. I hit a few balls with one shaft unchalked.
Played fine.
Mike bought it for the same reason, so now it is on ebay and even now it is a great price for a White cue...
And that, my friends, is the story of this White cue......
 
JMW cue

1pRoscoe said:
I've seen this cue trade hands MANY times in its short 6mo life - I think about 5 different people have owned it and it's for sale again....

It's the ebony JMW hoppe cue that has been posted here a few times, mfg date 08/07.... I have never seen one change hands this many times.

Anyone have any insight as to what is wrong with it? This is almost exactly the cue I'm looking for....

http://cgi.ebay.com/JAMES-WHITE-PRE...ryZ21212QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
PM sent.

James
 
Maybe, maybe not with this particular cue, but with a lot of cues on ebay (or fleabay as some refer to it) the sellers have their friends (schills) outbid actual buyers to see if they can get a higher bid(s) and sometimes (seems like alot of times) the phony buyers actually end up winning the item. Now the transaction is never completed so there is no record of the cue ever being sold when it is relisted and no mention of it. Sometimes, the seller will just say that the "buyer" could not pay for the item..... Also, some ebay sellers have multiple accounts which can aide them in the process of driving up a price on an item....good luck!
 
JustPlay said:
Maybe, maybe not with this particular cue, but with a lot of cues on ebay (or fleabay as some refer to it) the sellers have their friends (schills) outbid actual buyers to see if they can get a higher bid(s) and sometimes (seems like alot of times) the phony buyers actually end up winning the item. Now the transaction is never completed so there is no record of the cue ever being sold when it is relisted and no mention of it. Sometimes, the seller will just say that the "buyer" could not pay for the item..... Also, some ebay sellers have multiple accounts which can aide them in the process of driving up a price on an item....good luck!
I've seen that happen way too many times.... which is typically why I don't bid on cues on ebay too much anymore....
 
1pRoscoe said:
I've seen this cue trade hands MANY times in its short 6mo life - I think about 5 different people have owned it and it's for sale again
ROSCOE - it's not the 5 veneer blue book james white cue, this one has 4 veneers ( appx value $900 - $1100 )
 
jasxe said:
ROSCOE - it's not the 5 veneer blue book james white cue, this one has 4 veneers ( appx value $900 - $1100 )
In that case, I hope you have several - I'll give you $1000 for every hoppe JMW you have....
 
jasxe said:
ROSCOE - it's not the 5 veneer blue book james white cue, this one has 4 veneers ( appx value $900 - $1100 )

I also agree, I think the cue is over priced. I do not care about the Blue Book price however, because it is not a real guide for prices anyway. Its main purpose is designed to give you information about cue makers, and in my opinion cue prices should not even be listed. Cues like any commodity are only worth what they can be sold for, with all the cue makers today prices are being driven down do to the number of items for sale.

I think in the currently market the cue is over priced by $300 to $500 not because of the quality of the item, or because of who made it, but simply because it is a Plain Jane example of this gentleman's work. Today you can buy many cues for that cues asking price with a lot of additional work in them and this more than anything else in my opinion make it over priced.

I hope the seller gets what he asking, however, I doubt it will happen in the current market place. People are looking for deals / investments and while that is a great looking cue, it's value as currently priced is maxed out in my opinion.
 
1pRoscoe said:
In that case, I hope you have several - I'll give you $1000 for every hoppe JMW you have....

ill buy the rest if he doesnt want them

i also agree with craig. the bluebook is way way off. i almost wonder why it even exsists. the sad thing is most makers sumbitted the cost and examples. i never use it as a guide to a cues worth.
 
Last edited:
1pRoscoe said:
I've seen this cue trade hands MANY times in its short 6mo life - I think about 5 different people have owned it and it's for sale again....

It's the ebony JMW hoppe cue that has been posted here a few times, mfg date 08/07.... I have never seen one change hands this many times.

Anyone have any insight as to what is wrong with it? This is almost exactly the cue I'm looking for....

http://cgi.ebay.com/JAMES-WHITE-PRE...ryZ21212QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

two words, Ross :
Cue Flippers !
 
Jack Flanagan said:
two words, Ross :
Cue Flippers !

Either that's simply the case or there's in fact something wrong with the cue but nobody's saying....think that was the point of the thread :confused:
 
cueaddicts said:
Either that's simply the case or there's in fact something wrong with the cue but nobody's saying....think that was the point of the thread :confused:
I'm starting to side with this one.....
 
i don't know the seller or the cue,but i will pay $1200 for a new one or two,The cue price sounds fair to me and i doubt that the knockers have one for sale or know where to buy a new cue like this for the $1200,which is $200 more than their estimate.
Just as a manner of fair play,upon what evidence would these claims that something is wrong with the cue be based,does the seller offer his assurance that the cue is in new condition?
 
This whole thread is getting absurd.
First of all I have never seen a new JW cue on AZ for $900.00 to $1100.00.
Even if it is a Hoppe cue with only four points. Secondly I explained the history of the cue. Doesn't anyone ever read what is written here or is it lets just go off into left field and see where it takes you. A cue is worth what someone will pay for it. All cues have approx. values and the poor market pulls down the values. Simple economics, no money, no demand, prices drop. I along with a dozen more peoiple will buy all the JW Hoppe cues there are for $1000.00....Bring them on, but please don't give me this is all it's worth.....That is just BS.......
Now I said my peace.....For once maybe someone will read it and drop it....
 
Blue Book

jasxe said:
ROSCOE - it's not the 5 veneer blue book james white cue, this one has 4 veneers ( appx value $900 - $1100 )

The pricing in the Blue Book is subject to whatever the cue builder wants to put in there. I think it's time for the Blue Book 4th Edition
 
Back
Top