I think the things that endear a pro to his/her fans have mostly to do with their demeanor. Of course, they have to be good at what they do, but if they weren't they wouldn't be a pro to begin with. Appearance has something to do with it, but how they connect with the fans and how they relate to the fans is the biggest thing, IMHO. When I see a pro player at an event, if it reasonable to do so, I make a point of approaching them and speaking to them. I've had opportunity over the years to meet several pro pool players. Of those, here is my opinion FWIW:
Johnny Archer. Johnny lives near me. I have met him several times, played with him, taken lessons from him...I've sort of gotten to know him a little. Johnny is a quiet, unassuming, down to earth nice guy. He is always ready with a smile and a pleasant greeting. He is always willing to chat a little, sign autographs and even offer advice. That goes a long way with the fans.
Roger Griffis. Here is another nice guy. He's just a regular guy and is very friendly, fun-loving person. I met him in a pool hall in Kennesaw, GA several years ago (he was here for the Camel Pro Tour), and took him to another pool hall in Woodstock, GA because one of my buddies at that pool hall had said that he would play anyone in Bank Pool for any money...so I decided to call his bluff. He was more than a little shocked when Roger showed up to play and suddenly "remembered" that he had something else he had to do that night. That night was a blast. I would think that Roger would be pretty popular with the fans.
Allison Fisher. Allison seemed a little stand-offish. Not real friendly. She was with Gerda H. and Grady Matthews in Woodstock, GA. They were doing the "Play the pro" thing. Gerda was very nice and very approachable, as was Grady. Allison didn't seem to want to be bothered. She is a top-notch pool player and may just be skilled enough to offset some of her fan-relation issues. Watching her play is watching perfection, trying to talk to her is a different matter.
Nick Varner. Another nice, down-to-earth guy. He's quiet, but friendly enough.
Rudolfo Luat. Approachable, friendly...He didn't have a lot of time to talk, because he had a match.
Francisco Bustamante. Nice guy. Took time to go outside and pose for pictures with me and some of my friends.
Efren Reyes. Another nice guy. Seemed a little shy, maybe..but was friendly and approachable.
Weenie-Beanie Staton. One of the nicest pool players I've ever met. The man is a wealth of knowledge and has no problem sharing.
Jeremy Jones. I met Jeremy before he made the Pro tour. A helluva nice guy, and a great player.
Earl Strickland. I found Earl to be a lot friendlier than you would think from watching him play. I expected him to blow me off, but that's not what happened.
The ones above are the ones that I've actually gotten to spend more than a few seconds with, or were sort of blown-off by. I've met plenty of others, Mike Coltrane, Jeanette Lee, Jennifer Chen, Mika Immonen, Corey Deuel,, but only for a second...long enough to shake hands and say "Hi".
The only one that has really sort of been unfriendly toward me was Allison Fisher, and she may have just been having a bad night. I only met her the one time. Maybe she's really not like that. It hasn't kept me from being a fan, but not a die-hard one. I still like to watch her play, but sometimes I'm sort of rooting for her opponent depending on who it is.
