something that wasn't broken!
The duration of the contact between tip and ball is very short. That's the critical part . What the tip does before and after doesn't matter as long as the strike is accurate and on the right vector.
Developing a repeatable and consistent stroke was the reason for the bottle drill.
I use rail first practice shots to tell if I have struck whitey as I intended. A slight variation in the rotation of the cueball at contact with the rail will change the path whitey takes back to me. My first rail first practice shot has me shooting from the headspot and over the foot spot with intention of the cueball returning to strike my cue tip, which awaits 6 to 8 inches past where the cueball rested at strike.
A straight rebound isn't effected by the top or bottom on whitey. Rebounding at an angle will be effected by the speed and top or back spin. An important part of warm up on a new to me table is checking the rails. Well along with the level of the bed. Shrug

.