Blown call and lack of sportsmanship
- By GideonF
- Main Forum
- 69 Replies
Unless the ref can look at a replay - why would he change his decision- refs goof - part of every sport- if tape review is allowed a s part of a player request - yes I would agree with ref changes in decisions - but without tape review - ref changes based only on player admissions or disputes becomes a chaotic situation .
It’s unlikely, although not impossible, that the ref would change his call based solely on what the aggrieved player says. I can imagine a rare situation where the player might explain the physics (“if I’d hit the 2b first the CB would have gone left. Since it went right I must have hit the 1”) but it would take a rare occasion and a clear thinking ref.
I can think of many instances where the referee would change his decision based on what the *other* player says. This one is a good example. “Ref, the CB hit the 7b on the jump”. That player has no reason to lie and I can’t imagine the referee ignoring it to stick with their call. Or “I touched the ball” or “I feathered the CB” or “I double hit the CB” (all of which are routinely done in snooker).
There may well be instances where the referee is watching closely and sticks with their original call, like on a close hit where the referee is sure it wasn’t a foul. But I don’t think it’s most cases.