Blown call and lack of sportsmanship

Obvious foul. Awful call.

I'm as big on sportsmanship as anyone, but can it really be overridden? If the ref makes a bad call against me, can I argue to get it changed?

I don't know the full situation here, but i can see a case that if he can and has been screwed by bad ref calls then he can get one in his favor. That's what refs are for--to make calls.

I do the same thing in league. When someone gets called to watch a hit, it's an absolute coin flip whether or not they make the right call. I've had many erroneously go against me. So therefore if someone makes a bad call in my favor I also accept it. That's the established rules of the game.

If I'm calling it, I'm as honest and accurate as possible.

There may be difficult situations, but this isn’t one of them IMO. If he’d cleared the balls and then hits one of the 6 or the 8 in close proximity and the referee calls it good when it’s debatable, I can understand not saying anything.

The ref just completely missed the fact that the CB hit the 7. It’s like calling a ref to see if you get a rail and you move a ball (all ball fouls) with your back hand. I don’t think you’re off the hook because the ref didn’t see that. At the very least the player could have answered “the CB hit the 7” when asked and if the referee refuses to call it, at least he’s been honest.

In snooker, they call fouls on themselves all the time, including when the ref is right there and misses it. I’ve seen in it pro matches where the player double hits the CB and tells the ref. Or they touch the CB on a practice stroke. Or they touch a ball with their arm or something. IMO if the rules in pool don’t allow it they need to change the rules. Looking at the rules, though, the DO permit the althlete ask the referee to reconsider. It presumably applies to BOTH players, so the shooter here could say “CB hit the 7” and then the referee makes the correction (or not, I suppose).
9bbe740be3ca8a7afbe8368a841632ba.jpg

Mosconi/Reyes/WPM rankings

A nice writeup here from Thorsten but the line "several new business ventures have also demanded considerable time and energy" is not easy to get past. The slightest suggestion that he is too busy to play makes almost no sense in view of the very full array of tournaments in which he has played in 2026. In 2026, he competed in events on a very regular basis all over the globe, The idea that he's too busy to play in an event that a) covers his expenses, b) is held in the country in which he lives and c) ensures a payday of at least $20,000, does not add up.

I am as pro-Hohmann as one can be, and something here smells. If being well past one's playing prime and having had substandard tournament results in 2026 in WNT play (just two top ten finishes in WNT play) is a reason to disqualify oneself as unworthy of Mosconi inclusion, I guess we should expect the same of the 39-year-old Justin Bergman, who has shown nothing close to his form of ten years ago, has not contended in a single WNT event this year, and has not contended in a WNT event even once in his career. Of course, this won't happen and Bergman's selection seems absolutely assured now. I've always liked Justin and rooted for him, and I'll root as hard as anyone for him in Orlando. I hope he shines brightly when we get to Orlando ... but he is far less worthy of inclusion than Thorsten.

Maybe I am 100% wrong here, but I'll go out on a limb and suggest that Thorsten was either encouraged, pressured, or paid to disqualify himself from Mosconi consideration. This just doesn't feel right. If I'm wrong, I apologize to all concerned, but speculation based on an objective assessment of all the facts available is what this or any other pool forum is all about.
Sorry Stu, you missed the mark here. I had this very conversation with Thorsten during the Reyes Cup. Believe me he is sincere here. Thorsten is not a man easily influenced by others. He is very much his own man!

Filter

Back
Top