That is how I remember playing and scratches get ball in hand behind the line.
IF you scratch and a ball is made that ball spots up and you get the cue ball in the kitchen
and things keep rolling.
There are things about the old way that would appeal to some viewers but this is what we changed from
so there were obviously more people that wanted it changed.
There's various ways of playing. We often played Ring games and we had this real reckless way we played. On a scratch you shot from behind the line, if the next ball and rotation was behind the line you just threw it down and shot the next Ball. A majority of people that played if you scratched and the next ball in rotation was behind the line it spotted up.
That's why years ago the spot shot was such an integral part of the game. It came up all the time. There was always a debate about balls behind the line about whether you look down the line cross table or you use base of the ball to determine if it's behind the line.
It used to even come up on the break. Guy would break and somebody else would yell hey he wasn't behind the line. Lots of things for people getting arguments about.
I remember the first time I ever played one foul. The guy comes in who I knew and had not seen in a while and we often played I usually beat him. Well wherever he'd been playing one foul was how they played.
So I never used argue about rules I'll play anyway the other player wants to play. Wow he beat me for 200 pretty quick. I have no idea what I was doing as he's playing me safe and snookering me getting ball in hand. But the fact is it wasn't long before that was the only way anybody was playing and one foul became the rule of the day from then on.