Tournament Question

$TAKE HOR$E

champagne - campaign
Silver Member
I figured this would be the best place to ask this since a lot of people here have good tournament threads and ideas.

If you are going to run a tournament and have two calcutta's is it better to get to the final 8 and then redraw so that every player has an equal chance or run the second calcutta when it gets to the final 12 or so. This mostly applies to a tournament that is held on two days. I would think it would be best to run the tournament down to the final 8 on Saturday ( if its on a weekend ) then redraw on Sunday. Even with less players this would still put more money into it because not many people bid a great deal on someone if they are in the losers side, which is understandible.
 
I figured this would be the best place to ask this since a lot of people here have good tournament threads and ideas.

If you are going to run a tournament and have two calcutta's is it better to get to the final 8 and then redraw so that every player has an equal chance or run the second calcutta when it gets to the final 12 or so. This mostly applies to a tournament that is held on two days. I would think it would be best to run the tournament down to the final 8 on Saturday ( if its on a weekend ) then redraw on Sunday. Even with less players this would still put more money into it because not many people bid a great deal on someone if they are in the losers side, which is understandible.

I believe it is best to redraw and then hold an auction. I think it is unfair when bidders know who is playing who. Just my opinion for an aquweef.
 
I believe it is best to redraw and then hold an auction. I think it is unfair when bidders know who is playing who. Just an opinion from an aquweef.

That is another good point about the players already knowing who they play next.
 
Last edited:
I think the aquweef factors in.

To what extent, Im not sure, probably left to the experts.

Ken :)
 
I believe it is best to redraw and then hold an auction. I think it is unfair when bidders know who is playing who. Just my opinion for an aquweef.

Every calcutta that I've seen there is no re-draw. You can't change the natural path of the tournament for the auction.

Depending on the size of the field, the final 16 is ideal. The bid sheets should show the final 16 brackets.

Ray
 
Every calcutta that I've seen there is no re-draw. You can't change the natural path of the tournament for the auction.

Depending on the size of the field, the final 16 is ideal. The bid sheets should show the final 16 brackets.

Ray

Im not exactly sure what 1on1 meant but I think it was kinda the same thing I thought, as it would be more fair to the players and the buyers if there was a redraw. In a 64 player field for instance, when you reach the final 16 and have a second calcutta if there are 8 players on both sides then the players on the winners side have a big advantage over the losers side. Not that this is a bad thing but if it has already been decided that there will be a second calcutta and if it was held for the final 8 players then they could redraw afterwards and start as if it were an 8 player double elimination tournament. This would take roughly the same amount of time and pay more money because everyone would have an equal chance.
 
Don't change the draw!!

You can pick any number of players (probably even though) you want for the 2nd calcutta. Knowing who plays who has always been a big part of the 2nd calcutta in any tourney I have seen and it only seems to help the bidding.
 
I see advantages of both sides, a redraw and no redraw. Probably just depends on the participants if you are going to get much action. I bet it would help to at least make the finals maybe 1 long race.
 
i cant see how it could be fair for a player with no losses in a big event
to watch players with one loss become their equal from that point on
in fact it either becomes a single elimination or triple(for the one loss guys)
in which case someone is getting hurt
if the redraw leaves the one loss players on the left side then all that is being accomplished is to try to raise the bids(which may have been better before the redraw)
just my 2cents
 
A re-draw, discounting a prior loss is a bad idea. If he player is in the losers bracket, he should remain there.

Plus, how is it fair to the people that bought somone in the original calcutta.

They have a second calcutta in Olathe all the time, down at the final 16. No problems. Especially if you get a good player in the losers, he will still sell for a nice price. A bad player in the winners wont go for much.
 
Back
Top