Well, it sounds like everyone is in agreement that she is not a top player.
Wait... was that even up for debate? She is listed as a billiards celebrity and that she is. They made NO attempt to pass her off as anything more than she is. I may even agree with the attitude here IF she was touted as a top player. THEN it would be apropriate to call her skill into question. This event is NOT hinging on her ability to play, or teach.
If they also said the room owner would be on hand to meet players and introduce them to the room, would everyone jump all over that and say " wait, he can't play! This is an outrage!" He would have been mentioned as a room owner, NOT a player. His playing ability would not be a factor at all.
They have listed others who, most agree, would have more than enough credentials to teach. Again, what is the problem? Who loses here?
Let me say I am not well known in the pool world as a player, teacher, celebrity, etc. I KNOW FOR A FACT I am qualified to teach a beginner and introduce him to the game properly. I do not see why anyone listed would not be either. Does anyone think that the other players/teachers would sit there and let Shanelle give out incorrect instruction right in front of them?
To David: I have a great deal of respect for you, and I know you are a great teacher with a lot to offer any student. This in no way harms you or your livlihood. It can only help. There will always be way more casual players than serious ones. By increasing the number of people exposed to the game, it will only help everyone who makes a living from it. You say it cheapens what you do, or that it would lead some to believe that you are charging excessively. I disagree.
Does the fact that I can buy a brand new cue for $50 hurt say, Southwest cues? They are not going after the same market. Can sombody say that Southwest charges too much, and I would never pay more than $100 for a cue? Yes, and some do, but that does not affect the value or the sales of their cues.
If I have a promotional event and give away a FREE southwest cue, has this hurt Southwest or the cuemaking industry? No, it has given them even more exposure to some who may have not heard of southwest or is familliar with custom cues. Do you really think that sombody will call up southwest or sombody selling a southwest and say " you know, I saw one of these given away for free, so I think you are crazy to want $1800 for that cue"
I remember mentioning that I was going to take a pool lesson, and someone was just amazed that I would feel the need to do that. " Why would you need a pool lesson?" They did not even know that anyone would need one, they figured you just banged some balls around for awhile, and you gradually got better.
An event like this is a GREAT introduction for new and almost new players. This increases the awareness of the game, billiard instruction, and this pool room.
Before anyone throws some more criticism out there, WILL YOU PLEASE TELL ME WHO THIS IS HURTING? Who is losing out here. I want to know who is specifically being wronged. A real world, possible worst case scenario.
Do you realize that there are a large number of people who are just flat out NOT comfortable to just walk into a pool room? They have seen too many movies where fighting and all kinds of bad behavior goes on in them. They have NEVER been in a pool room before, so they do not know how true it may or may not be. So they will not risk it.
Or at the very least, are not comfortable with the possibility of looking foolish while trying to figure things out. I bet just about everyone here was introduced to the game by someone first, BEFORE walking into a pool room. Or you were brought there by someone else.
Events like these encourage new players to come in and try it out. They know they will be in the company of others who are still learning. They know they will have some guidance as to how to do things.
I just do not see what the harm is that is being done here. Anyone who thinks this is such a bad thing is welcome to put on a FREE promotion and show us all the proper way to promote the game. Or you could just continue to sit back and criticize others for even trying. If you want it done the way you want it done, then you are the best qualified to do it.
I would welcome ALL genuine attempts to promote this game on any and all levels.
Jw