I ordered 2 Victory Hard tips, one for myself and one for a friend. After hitting a few shots the third layer down completely mushroomed out! After breaking it in, and re shaping the tip it still played like a soft. My friend decided to not install his after trying mine out. I would not order one again.
I found the best tip for me is a Kamui med-soft brown. But I think they stopped making them. I've had 6 installed and 4 played lights out. The other 2 had glazing issues but still played well.
Currently I have a Tiger Onyx and it plays extremely well and is very consistent from one tip to another. I just don't have the soft extreme juice shots without miscuing like I did with the Kamui MS brown.
I have tried, Kamui SS black, S black, M black, Kamui brown MS, M brown. All the Kamui's played great but most had glazing issues. As long as you stay on top of them and give them a scuff now and then you will enjoy them.