I don't think Mr. Incardona meant anything disrepectful to the foreign players but that doesn't mean what he slipped up and said couldn't be viewed as offensive.
Also mentioning his track record and knowing his history doesn't do any good for the people that don't already know it.
If the pool community wants to be respected and have any sort of interity then it needs to bring some sort of professionalism along with it, and this instance along with all of its defenders is yet another reason why no one can take it seriously.
Being an announcer/commentator is a job. If you're not up to the 8 or 9 hour task then don't moan and groan about it. Take it seriously and allow yourself the 2 minutes it takes to learn a few one syllable names. Leave the comedy to the comedians and please spare us all your life stories and quit tying to one-up the other commentator by guessing what shot the player will choose next.
You never hear snooker commentators making corny jokes or talking about what they ate or burping and making fun of other players names. Maybe that's one of the reasons snooker is held in such high regard in Europe, because it's taken seriously.
I bet a lot more people on here would be a lot more butt hurt if they were watching the US players play in Japan while the foreign commentators were the ones making fun of our American names. "Great safe by Shane Van Booger" or "Nice shot Girl Strickland". That stuff might sound funny to a middle school kid or whatever but if I'm somewhere playing and you make fun of my last name like it's a joke then I'll have something to say about it.
I gotta agree with most of what you've said here.
Pool will always stay small time if most of its enthusiasts are willing to accept anything less than professionalism in their sport. Sure it's just a few folks watching but it is going worldwide. So no offense was meant but I doubt mocking an Asian player's name is going to go so well in the Asian markets where, I would think, all of the stream sponsors are wishing to sell product.
Times change and what was acceptable 10 years ago in life, the media, or locker room may not be so anymore. And we've all become more media savy. Nowadays there are seven year old kids putting out near broadcast quality video on YouTube. The bar has been raised regardless of what the commentators are being paid.
Which brings me to this: as most here know I played a streamed match a few months back. I am told that at one point the stream approached 800 viewers. There were two commentators in the booth for that match, Jamison Neu and Freddy Agnir. Jamison knows me from Missouri, but Freddy not so much, though our paths frequently cross on the groups. I doubt either guy was getting paid and were probably just doing it to be part of the show. But before the match Freddy did something that impressed me -- he came up to me and asked me a series of questions about what I'd been doing lately pool-wise, what some of my accomplishments were, and a little bit about my background. I knew exactly what he was doing: gathering a little intel so he could do a professional job as a commentator in the booth.
We could all use a little bit more of that.
Lou Figueroa