This is the feedback that I was hoping for.
Seems to me, this is the best solution:
- Set forum default to "Last Post Time"
- Set default to only allow thread starter to reply in their own thread.
- Set default to only allow thread replies every 48 hours.
These are all vBulletin features and can be activated immediately.
The only downside is that members must contact the thread starter via private message or email. The upside is that members will no longer be able to comment about the cue playing "lights out" or saying how nice of a guy the thread starter is.
It is very unfortunate that the same members had to ruin it over and over for others, but you can't fix stupid. I would be very happy to moderate the forums if it were asked of me, but if a good system is in place, I don't think much moderation will be needed.
These are great ideas – it's a good way…
…in the German Forums we are allowed only 5 items at the same time (which is totally okay).
If we start a 6th item, the oldest one closes automatically!!! :yeah:
AND:
no other people can bump your thread – so the „bet it's a good player“, „great guy“, „would buy it if I had the money“ and other bumpedys won't happen! :idea2:
This is a great thing, cause if someone's interested, he can contact you by PM!
But the setting now makes no sense to me:
also from the buyers perspective – maybe I'm interested in a cue (and can't decide between a few cues by now, or have a limited budget, or or or…) and the seller bumps his cue with a price reduction – I won't see it, if the cue has been posted some weeks ago!
I DON'T WANT TO GO THROUGH MAYBE 17 SITES to see the cue is reduced.
Luckily I found my own way – whenever I come in here, the „For Sale“-section is sorted by last post…
…which makes the most sense to me, so I'll just have to go through maybe the first 3 sites to see all new posts, bumps, etc…