I've been outta the loop for awhile and haven't watched any streams for awhile.
So my question is this...Was Bigtruck nd his PPV stream setup in house at the CSI event or were they say at another location across town, or in a different state?
Thanks!
Different locations, but both in Las Vegas. Big Truck was set up at Good Timez Billiards.
A good business uses leverage all the time. So what if Sky wants to play in the Mars open the same weekend as turning stone where the winner is guaranteed to take home $40,000. Would you say turning stone is unethical by offering MC points?
What if the Mars open guarantees $250,000 to the winner. Would they be using leverage? Would that leverage be enough to make him go to the Mars open?
In both instances the player has a choice.
Nothing unethical about it. It is called competition
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Why the Silence?
So, What Really Happened?
Oscar Dominguez and Skyler Woodward had agreed to play their match on July 22 and 23 beginning at 4pm each day and then asked Ray Hansen to stream it via PPV. I assume that Ray and the two players would split the PPV revenue in some fashion – as is usually the case. Neither of the three parties knew that we had already scheduled and announced The Kamui Challenge and The Tiger Challenge for July 22 and 23 beginning at 5pm each day.
When I saw the flyer for their match, I immediately called Ray Hansen. Ray informed me that he was not the organizer so the scheduling was out of his control. He was simply asked to stream it. I then called Oscar. He was completely unaware of the conflict and was very apologetic. After discussing possible solutions to avoid the conflict, Oscar’s girlfriend (Desiree Rivera) proposed a solution. She suggested that the Oscar/Skyler match begin at 2pm each day and take a long break at 5pm when our challenge matches began. This would prevent a situation in which two PPV streams were running simultaneously and people that wanted to watch both could do so. Oscar, Ray, and I all agreed that this was a good solution and would benefit everyone.
Oscar then contacted Skyler to get his approval. A few minutes later, Oscar called me back and said that Skyler’s backer said, “No…the match will be played as originally agreed.” I then contacted Skyler and explained the entire situation to him. He seemed to understand and said that he would speak with his backer and get back with me shortly. A day later, he still had not contacted me so I reached out again. He said that he hadn’t spoken with his backer yet but would do so soon. I expressed the urgency and he seemed to understand. Another day went by and I reached out to him again. He then said that they were not going to move the match up to accommodate us. I explained to him that running two PPV streams would not be good for either of us because we may split the audience rather than giving people the opportunity to watch both. I again asked him and his backer to reconsider so we could work with each other rather than against each other. Again, they said, “No.” I then explained to Skyler that his unwillingness to compromise would damage our live stream viewership, interfere with our ability to recover the cost of paying the players and the stream crew, and hurt our sponsors – Kamui and Tiger. He still said, “No.” Finally, I told him that if he maintained his position to intentionally harm us and our sponsors, we would have to seriously consider whether or not to accept his entry into our events (which he had not yet registered for). He and his backer finally agreed to compromise.
I then informed Oscar and Ray that Skyler agreed. Ray and I agreed that he would encourage his viewers to flip over to our challenge match and we would encourage our viewers to flip over to his later in the evening. We would work with each other rather than compete for the same tiny market of PPV viewers.
Bullying?
What happened was not bullying. CSI guaranteed $30,000 to be added to the US Open events and we had to pay a live stream crew of seven (7) people for 11 days. We recover some (definitely not all) of that money through sponsorships, VIP seats, and live stream revenue. Additionally, our sponsors pay for exposure. A competing PPV stream scheduled directly on top of our two challenge matches would limit their exposure and make them less likely to be a sponsor in future years. Without sponsors, there are either no events or smaller prize funds in the future – both of which are bad for the players. Our position was simple and logical…if you intentionally harm us or our sponsors, you may not be welcome to play in our events. That’s not bullying…that’s accountability for your choices.
There also seems to be some notion that people have a right to play in various independent events produced by individual businesses. That is untrue. Like most businesses, the entities that provide the funding have the right to refuse service to anyone. Although we want everyone to participate and have equal opportunity at our events, we are not required to service someone who intentionally harms us, our sponsors, or our other members. This holds true for someone who organizes a competing live stream directly on top of ours or someone who publically attacks us on social media. They have the absolute right to do those things and we have the absolute right to not do business with them. Again, that’s not bullying…that’s accepting the consequences of your actions.
Final Thoughts
So, there it is. Those are the details. You have the right to agree or disagree. You have the right to continue to post whatever comments you wish. You have the right to publically criticize or attack me or CSI anytime you wish. None of that really bothers me or will deter us from pushing forward and making a real difference in an otherwise tragic industry. This will be the last time that I ever reply on AZBilliards to a “demand for answers” based on a contrived conspiracy by people who contribute nothing but negativity and divisiveness. So, if you ever wonder why there is no response from CSI on this forum, there is your answer.
To all of those good people who make up the silent majority here, I don’t blame you for not posting here and we truly thank you for your support. Thank you.
The US OPEN 8-ball and 10-ball were both MC points events.
This is crazy. I wonder what would have happened if Oscar and Ray also disagreed to Ozzy's terms. Would Ozzy throw away his 5 year friendship with Ray and 2 year friendship with Oscar for the sake of 2 nights of streaming, while also banning Oscar and Skylar from playing in future CSI events?
That's like Big truck telling Shane or Mike Dechaine to take a break while playing their match or else neither one of them can ever play in a Fight Night challenge match, even if Ozzy and Mark agreed. What does Shane have to do with the scheduling of the match? And by the way if this was the other way around, Ozzy would have definitely not agreed to something like this if Bigtruck had asked.
What ever happened to friendly competition? Is CSI not confident enough in their product that they have to strong arm a minor? Ozzy's response just raises more unanswered questions.
Does anybody else see as bizarre the adoration for and the reverence given in this community to high-stakes gambling matches? I don't mean serious matchups between top players--that SHOULD get our respect.
But what I find weird is if I say Sky's playing Morra a race to 20, the first question is "what are they playing for?" The answer could be $500 or it could be $20,000. If it $500, the matchup seems like not such a big deal; If it's $20,000, it is a big deal. Why is this?
Think about it . If it is $20,000, that means Sky's backer(s) are gambling against Morra's backer(s). So what? You can watch people at craps table bet it up too.. Is it really that exciting?
Where it really gets weird is we then take the best and most promising players in the country and the world, and some high roller has them by the short hairs.
It is naive to think Ozzy was really communicating with Skylar Woodward. Ozzy was communicating THROUGH Skylar Woodward with some unknown-to-most-of-us gambler.
Such unknowns wouldn't be able to treat our best pool players like puppets if we didn't show such reverence to "big stakes" matchups.
We are a pretty weird group--essentially high rolling ourselves.
Well, when Ray is putting up the prize fund, then he would be on the same negotiating ground as CSI who had 30K on the line.
One thing that hasn't been mentioned is that most likely the players were all here in Vegas because if the CSI events. Without that, it would be much more difficult for them to have this challenge match. The hardest part, getting them together in the same place at the same time, was already done.
Personally, I think Ray was very smart in all this, by setting this up when they were all together anyway.
Royce
The part of your comments that I take exception to was this:
You stated
"It was not just their own event they had to threaten Sky with, they used points for events they do not run or own to work with, and that should not be the case."
Yes, they were.
But they were also CSI events.
The part of your comments that I take exception to was this:
You stated
"It was not just their own event they had to threaten Sky with, they used points for events they do not run or own to work with, and that should not be the case."
This is the part I responded to.
So tell me, Celtic, just exactly were did your statements come from?
Were you speaking of something you know about directly?
Were you passing something along that you heard, or, were you simply speculating as to what the truth was?
In any case your statement was wrong. And when I pointed it out,you tried to dodge it.
Royce
I give Ozzy a compliment and praise, but thereafter get called out for calling him a "kid." Sheesh! Everybody is a kid to me at 61 years old. I meant no disrepect whatsoever. Seems like women are easier prey on this forum for some.
You-all need to let it go. I think decisions are made for the betterment of tournaments sometimes. Not everybody will agree with these decisions.
It's like the referee calling a good hit or bad hit in the middle of a match. He comes to the table, watches the hit, and then makes the wrong call. Everybody in the audience knows it's the wrong call, but he's the referee and the final decision-making authority. There ain't a damn thing anybody can do about it. In the end, the referee is the authoritative body. In an event like CSI put on, CSI is the authoritative body. Their decisions are made for the betterment of the event. I don't know why this is so hard to understand.
About Skylar and his backer, it's their prerogative to do what is best for them. Skylar may go the way of an action player and not be interested in being a tournament soldier, so who gives a f*** then about Mosconi points? Who can blame him? There's more money in action than tournaments, these days. Go Skylar, go!
I really like how the number of $30k keeps getting tossed around as if it had anything to do with Sky playing Oscar . . .
huh?
It's like the referee calling a good hit or bad hit in the middle of a match. He comes to the table, watches the hit, and then makes the wrong call. Everybody in the audience knows it's the wrong call, but he's the referee and the final decision-making authority. There ain't a damn thing anybody can do about it. In the end, the referee is the authoritative body. In an event like CSI put on, CSI is the authoritative body. Their decisions are made for the betterment of the event. I don't know why this is so hard to understand.
About Skylar and his backer, it's their prerogative to do what is best for them. Skylar may go the way of an action player and not be interested in being a tournament soldier, so who gives a f*** then about Mosconi points? Who can blame him? There's more money in action than tournaments, these days. Go Skylar, go!
Great point. If Skylar's backers and him do not have the same goals maybe it is time to find a different backer.
Play with your own money and then you can make your own decisions and do what is best for you
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
BTW, I think you'd be a shoe-in for Saturday Night Live with your talent and quick wit. I'm not kidding. You should be putting your energies into something like that instead of this pool world. You need a promoter.