IMHO The first priority is to try to get them from the maker. Some don't like to make them, but that is the first place to ask especially if you are having the cue made IMHO. Original protectors by the maker himself are a great thing IMHO.
Next, if the maker does not want to, they might supply the matching ring material (if you have fancy rings) to a reputable maker (Like Baxter) to make protectors. Can't hurt to ask.
Baxter is a great option from all I know, and perhaps especially if materials are supplied from the cue maker to make it easier to match.
I don't think anybody is stepping up to do what Alton did.
I spoke to Baxter about getting a set made and never pulled the trigger. He was really very nice. In addition, I wanted some special things inlaid in the end and he would put them in if I supplied them so it seems he is open to using supplied materials to achieve a design.
Just my thoughts on the matter.
If I were getting a BB made, I would certainly ask if it could come with matching joint caps. :smile:
Lastly, I hope to see you show off the cue here when you get it! :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:
.
.