How was/is he entertaining? All I see are the strange stroke, stance and mannerisms.
I cant find any videos of Keith playing 10 ball or straight pool, just 9 ball and of the matches out there on youtube, none of them have any excellence in play. That might be because he is past his prime in those videos, but I think most pro`s today would run right through him.
I`m not trying to put the guy down, I just don`t see what the fuzz is about, apart from McCready having a role in The colour of money.
I dont know how old McCready is in the videos of him playing that`s on youtube and if that is way past his prime, did something change drastically? Many of the big names in the 80`s and 90`s still play pretty sporty today, look at Earl, Bustamante or Efren.
I'll try and answer your questions without getting too long. Nah...that ain't going to happen...it will get long. But I think you will understand better.
I'm sure you have seen videos of deathball and the likes of him before. Lots of constant banter going on, and all watching like they are seeing a train wreck. They are appalled by the antics, but can't stop watching.
Well, Keith was exactly the opposite in some parts. While Keith wasn't constant banter, he was far from silent, and you never knew when he was going to say something. Keith's banter was very rarely used to put down his opponent. Instead, it was used to talk to the balls as if they could hear him and should be obeying him, or to laugh at himself, or just some funny quip.
Odds are, when Keith spoke, the audience would be laughing. You never knew what he would come up with, and his timing and delivery were worthy of a great comedian. People were always watching to hear what he would say next. He'd even have his opponents laughing.
As far as Keith's actual play goes....greatness can almost be used as an oxymoron. More fitting might be the phrase "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times."
We all know roughly how to match up with others. Most peoples game is fairly consistent. Everyone one also has an "A" game that will peak out at you for a little while that you have to allow for. But, we also know pretty much what their "A" game consist of and can allow for it.
Keith was not "most people". He was very unique in several ways. Any books on positive thinking should have his picture on the cover. Where you and I learn to play the odds on shots over time, that never applied to Keith. His motto was "If that ball is makeable, I can make it and I'm shooting it." He never learned the consequences of missing. He did learn the consequences of belief. He never saw a makeable shot that he didn't like.
With a normal style of play, that is, playing the odds on any given shot, there is naturally a limit on performance. You will never take on the tough shots if there is an easier safe to play. And it is easy to make the argument of that is the correct way to play. The standard, so to speak.
Keith is your non-standard issue model. He is the model that breaks the "rules" and still manages to get the job done. With Keith's style and attitude, there actually are no limits on what can be achieved.
If one can even say that Keith had an average game, it would probably be somewhere around mid to upper level pro. Problem is, you could never say he was having an average day, let alone an average period of time. His game probably fluctuated more than any of the other big names.
If Keith got his "mixture" right, there was NO limit on what he might do to you. And, by mixture, I don't mean it in the usual sense of drugs and booze that was so prevalent, many relied on, and Keith imbibed in also. (I don't know if he used drugs or not, but it was so prevalent at the time that he may have) Rather, by mixture, I mean the complete synergy between mind and body. For him to picture it happening was the same as it actually happening.
Because of that, Keith's high game was higher than anyone else's. And by a noticeable difference. It had no limit as to how high it went, nor to how long it might last. It might last an hour, or it might last days or even weeks.
How does one go about matching up with someone that you know has a gear waiting in the wings that you have trouble even imagining? How does that not put fear in one's heart when thinking of playing him?
Was Keith beatable? Sure he was. He got his butt handed to him a number of times. His "mixture" wasn't always on. Heck, he probably had days like you and me where he couldn't pocket the cb with ball in hand. lol But, for several decades there, he was one scary dude to play. Playing him was truly a gamble because you never knew which Keith was going to show up, nor how long he would last. But, in that time frame, the great Keith was there often enough to put fear in everyone.
Now, I may be all wet on this part, but I don't think I am. Keith's game changed forever when the realities of life kicked in. In his prime, he lived for the action. Whether on the pool table, or something else. He lived moment by moment. He was rich today, broke tomorrow.
Money was nothing more than a tool he needed to do what he so loved doing. Then, life hit him smack dab in the face. He was taught, by his now other half, and by others, that money is more than just a tool for pool, poker, and other fun things. Essentially, he grew up. Along with that, came the inevitable fear of losing. I believe that became the death toll of the great Keither with the ether. His top game became harder and harder to achieve until it became almost impossible to achieve anymore. You can't play without fear and have fear of losing and what losing will cost you. You either have total belief in yourself, or you don't. There really is no middle ground. The belief that there is a middle ground is only an illusion we tell ourselves to feel better.
In summary, Keith's high game showed us all what is possible. Even when we didn't believe what we were seeing. He achieved what no other did, with the arguable exception of Mosconi. But, Keith also kept everyone laughing while doing it.