My review as promised...
Received the complimentary soft three weeks ago Monday. Put it on and played about 50 games on the worst possible table I could find. Dirty cloth and balls, dead rail valley bar box. I figured this would be the best test since I'd have to shoot much harder than I normally do.
Mushroomed considerably. But on the other hand, by the time I was done playing I wasn't even aware I was shooting with a tip that wasn't my normal Ultraskin Pro.
View attachment 780723
Trimmed it and played another 50-60 games over the next couple days. Mushroomed a bit but not terrible. Didn't get a picture.
Trimmed it once more and looked like this after.
View attachment 780724
Played another 100+ games over the next couple weeks and it seemed to settle in fine and only very slightly mushroomed. Sorry about the fuzzy picture but you get the idea.
View attachment 780725
So after a couple trimmings it seems to settle down and I don't have any doubt that it would be pretty much maintenance free for the rest of it's life.
Play-ability: After my very first 20 games or so I couldn't even tell I wasn't playing with my normal Ultraskin Pro. I've always played with soft tips starting with Elkmasters for decades then on to Kamui Super Softs and finally settling on The Ultraskin Pros. The Recoil Soft will play pretty much like any of those. The sound, while a little different, didn't bother me at all. All the english I could get with my normal playing tips I could get with these as well. Draw was the only thing that suffered but not enough to be a deal breaker.
After coming back to this thread a few times and reading how confident Bulletproof is in their Hard Recoil I decided to try one out as I have a few customers that prefer hard tips and I wanted to be able to have some knowledge to potentially recommend them.
Installed...
View attachment 780727
View attachment 780728
Installation is easy with these tips but as mentioned earlier in the thread you cannot use the normal burnishing methods. To get a nice burnished look on these tips just use a super sharp blade to trim and leave it alone.
I played with the Hard Recoil at our weekly Friday night tourney last week and ended up winning the thing! Draw, as mentioned was much better and I did have to adjust a bit to keep from over-drawing. But it didn't take me long to adjust to the hard tip which was surprising. I don't like the sound of the hit as much as the soft but I'm going to leave this on for a while as I seem to be shooting a little more consistent with it.
Same hard tip after about 70 games...
View attachment 780734
As you can see, no mushrooming at all, retaining it's shape well and holds chalk even if I forget to chalk for a couple balls.
I'm still not completely sold on moving to the hard but will play with it for the next month or two and give it a sporting chance. If I had to try to explain the hit, it sounds like a hard, moves the ball like a hard, draws like a hard, but hits more to the medium side. I know, weird right?
Thanks to the guys at Bulletproof for bringing these to the market and the offer to try the complimentary soft and for the easy ordering and quick shipping!