Too much of a good thing in a "small" market area. I really wish Buffalo had come over here to have a third place because we (the Mississippi Gulf Coast players) are lost in a literal pool desert. Keeping a place open is one thing, making money is entirely another. Hu is absolutely correct, management is critical, but so is clientele and another Buffalo's in Chalmette was spreading it a little too thin.
Jim-Bobs in Gulfport provides a good example -- it was a great room for many years, and it grew and nurtured a thriving pool culture around here. Hell, folks were always coming over here from New Orleans and Mobile to enjoy what we had. Then came Katrina and a whole lot of water and other problems.
For some reason, Jim and Bob never reopened. The new owner/manager after Katrina was a great guy and a good business man, but he just did not understand pool and pool players. A big part of the problem is a good pool hall is so much more than just tables and a bar. An essential element is pool clientele and the essential element in attracting and maintaining a pool clientele is management. Behind every successful pool room is an owner/manager who knows and loves pool and pool players. It just won't work any other way.