"As the player field narrows, to be fair to all of the competitors, the last four 9’ tables used in the tournament are the 4.5” CP, not the tighter 4.25” tables which seems fair."
Why bother having 4.25 inch pockets if they won't even use them for the last few rounds of a tournament? Wow. Just goes to show how misguided this small-pocket trend is.
Not really…….the regular players enjoy practicing, competing and gambling on the tougher tables. It sharpens their skills and makes playing on any tables with bigger pockets easier. I’d practice with 4” pockets if I could. In fact, I still use occasionally Pro Pocket Reducers on the 4.25” CP tables to practice with. When I practice, I concentrate on precision & repeatability. I’ll practice my stroke on a spot shot and then close my eyes when I shoot and listen for the sound of the OB dropping.
Sometimes I am disappointed to open my eyes and don’t see the cue ball on the table……Oops……Oh well, gotta go fetch the cue ball out of one of the CPs. The Golden Fleece of pool is to have a pool stroke so straight and steady it seldom deviates from the intended path striking and extending beyond the cue ball. All the guys I play with prefer the toughest tables and admittedly, Diamond pool tables aren’t known for playing EZ.
The reasoning behind using the 4.5” CP tables as the last tables in the field serves 2 purposes. Someone that hasn’t played very much, and sometimes not at all, on the tables with smaller pockets is to not put them at a disadvantage to finish in the $ as the field narrows, which of course they logically could be. Unfortunately, it also gives competitors that prefer the 4.25” CP tables a little more edge, at least mentally, when competing on the tables with 1/4” larger pockets.
It is really fair since players that could enter the tournament might be brand new patrons to Sierra Billiards in contrast to players that regularly play there on a monthly or yearly memberships. It is obvious you are not a fan of tighter pockets &
I’m not here to try changing your opinion. The good news is if you ever were to compete in the SB tournament and got to advance in the field, i.e., compete for the payout $, you’d be playing on Diamond pool tables with the larger 4.5” CP.
The only conclusion I can come to is pool players have likes and dislikes. It comes down to one’s preferences. I can play pool and enjoy it borrowing a 19.5 oz. pool cue. However, I’d enjoy it more if the cue was an ounce lighter like my pool cues are. The same applies to tight pockets which is what I prefer. The harder the table, the more apparent a player’s skills become and 4.5” pockets are already demanding. I just like the pool tables to be very challenging.
When I run the pool table practicing 14.1, or 8/9/10 ball, with 4.25” CP, it is enormously more satisfying knowing that the table had really tight pockets but the alternative is also true. Accomplishing it on an old Brunswick with 5” CP is different.