Softshot..."This is a personal game, with individual requirements and each individual has their own requirements. ANYONE who says he has the answer to all variables is a LIAR!!"
"Liar"...maybe....but maybe just somewhat self-deluded.
But on the other hand, Mosconi DID pocket 526 in an exhibition and Babe Cranfield DID pocket 768 in a practice session in front of witnesses. (Plus he was such a GENTLEMAN of the highest order that if he SAID he did...then he did! Book it Danno.
So, it's a little hard to sustain the view that no one knows everything there is to know about aiming.
What we do know though, is that pool is played by human beings who succumb to losses of concentration, fatigue, substance abuse, personal family stresses etc. that can cause a player who knows EXACTLY how to aim a shot to miss.
Additionally, aiming and therefore pocketing balls while a BIG percentage of the game is not by any strecth if the imagination, the entire game. It may not even be HALF the game. The other huge issue is, of course, shape.
knowing many systems allows you to choose the right system... for any given shot. sometimes its a matter of merging two systems or more... to allow you to make a given shot.
EXACTLY...which is why IMHO, the discussion of various aiming systems EVEN THOUGH each may have certain flaws, is valuable.
Personally, for shots that are more difficult, I will use one system to confirm another.
We all have shot types that are on our "most frequently missed" list...or we should have such a list and if a given system worked on JUST THOSE shot types, we could significantly boost our win percentage.
Frankly, the methods I use are hyper-accurate and I find myself missing due to the very same variables you refer to but the big ones for me are squirt compensation because it is so variable..and inside english. But give me a center ball hit where shape or scratching are not issues...and I can be pretty dangerous.
It is just STUPID of me that I don't set up 100 inside english shots a day in practice...but I don't..so I guess I'm stupid...or hopefully better put, I just don't have the obsessive-compulsive disorder that most great champions have.
One top WPBA pro has been quoted as saying that when she misses a shot in practice, she will shoot it ONE HUNDRED TIMES.
Another told me personally that for months, she shot NOTHING in practice but drills...PERIOD...didn't run a single rack.
Anyway, I agree with your views and just suggest that people who have things to contribute on the subject of aiming are not fundamentally kooks unless they suggest that their systems/methods/techniques are infallible.
And those who say "Oh no, not another aiming thread" better not miss much themselves. (-:
Regards,
Jim