News Flash sports fans, Mr. Brewer has hit the nail on the head !..."Fixing" pool, is not possible !...In the first place, it is NOT broken !..It is, what it always was, a skill/game that very few mastered, and even fewer cared about watching !..The occasional movie, (if its good enough) will spur interest for a while, then it reverts back to what it ALWAYS was...A pastime that is enjoyed by many, but taken seriously, by VERY few !
In fact, if it were not for the two movies, and Fats successful (but brief) spurt, I would be surprised if CSI, DCC,TAR, or AZ Billiards, would even exist !..Mark Griffin spotted the only way to make a buck, by improving bar table league participation, and a half dozen other 'acronym's' jumped on the bandwagon !..Now, I fear even league play, has reached its saturation point !..
All the tens of thousands of "Joe Six-pack" league player's want out of pool, is a night out of the house, and a few beers with the guy's !..Mention the words 'One Pocket', 'SVB', 'TAR' or 'AccuStats' and you may as well be speaking Chinese !..This is the "fan base" we are trying to attract ???
What about the other 297 million American's, that don't even play pool ?..However, it is a very safe bet, they know who Tiger Wood's and Tom Brady are ! (Earl Strickland, Efren,..not a prayer)...If someone like Jay, CJ, or Badi, can tap into a market that doesn't even EXIST...It will be more amazing than ObamaCare becoming popular !...But me, and every other pool degenerate, will keep hoping they find a way !
You grow the sport - or any activity - by growing the number of participants and keeping them.
Of course regular league players often don't know about one pocket. But the very fact that Jane Doe is playing POOL instead of on bowling league means that there are more folks beside her doing the same thing. And out of a larger amount of people playing comes more people who get into pool in a deeper way who do learn what one pocket is and want to play it.
In other words a larger pie feeds more people. And with a larger stable base pool can find money to produce shows that make pool interesting. Snooker is freaking BORING but the production of it has made it interesting. In China there are at least three magazines that are REAL glossy heavy books devoted mainly to snooker players with in-depth interviews and tons of content. They actually have ads for giant brand names in them.
In England the exploits of Snooker stars are tabloid material. Ok that's how it developed and Snooker had the backing of the BBC early as a test bed for all their broadcasting innovations. But it shows that a boring game can be made interesting for the non-playing public. People will care for and cheer for players they get to know.
Ok it's 2013 in America and the question is whether there is any room in the average American's mind to spend on pool and pool players? I don't know. But I do know that when I see adults on Facebook showing pictures of a backpack with the images of the Duck Dynasty characters on it and saying how much they want one then I have to believe that the beautiful game of pool can be packaged and sold to these people because we certainly have some characters that are more interesting than the Duck Dynasty guys.
But if no one actually writes the script and no one hits the road to sell it then it's a certainty that all we will have is continued hand-wringing and lamenting how bad off pool is. And you're right, in some senses pool is not broken, there are still rooms, there are still tournaments, there is still some action. Pool addicts will always be around.
The game itself in all the various forms will never die. Will it ever reach the heights it deserves? Maybe not, probably not, but it would be nice in my lifetime to see pool and its players be well known and well regarded among the general public. At the very least and well before that I think that pool in the USA can become consistent and stable with a pro tour and a broad base to support it.
That's doable right now with the resources we have with no need to look outside the industry.
Instead of sitting on the sidelines I call for Mark and Badi and Greg and likeminded people to get together and be the change they want to see rather than hoping others will see the errors of their ways and come to the table.